Num quisquam scit cur porta hodie tam sero aperiatur?

Breakdown of Num quisquam scit cur porta hodie tam sero aperiatur?

scire
to know
hodie
today
aperire
to open
cur
why
porta
the gate
tam
so
sero
late
quisquam
anyone

Questions & Answers about Num quisquam scit cur porta hodie tam sero aperiatur?

What does num do at the beginning of the sentence?

Num introduces a yes/no question that usually suggests the speaker expects the answer no.

So:

  • Num quisquam scit ... ? = Does anyone know ... ? / Surely no one knows ... ?

It gives the question a slightly skeptical tone. A learner should compare it with:

  • -ne = neutral question
  • nonne = question expecting yes
  • num = question expecting no

Why is quisquam used here instead of quis?

Quisquam means anyone or anybody, especially in contexts like:

  • negatives
  • questions
  • conditionals
  • other non-assertive environments

Since num creates a yes/no question with a somewhat negative expectation, quisquam is very natural.

So:

  • quisquam = anyone at all
  • quis would not be the normal choice here

Why is scit in the indicative, but aperiatur in the subjunctive?

Because the sentence contains two different clauses:

  1. Num quisquam scit ... ?
    This is the main clause, so scit is in the indicative.

  2. cur porta hodie tam sero aperiatur
    This is an indirect question introduced by cur (why), and in Latin indirect questions normally take the subjunctive.

So:

  • scit = indicative, main statement/question
  • aperiatur = subjunctive, because it is inside an indirect question

This is one of the most important grammar points in the sentence.


What exactly is cur porta hodie tam sero aperiatur?

It is an indirect question.

The direct version would be something like:

  • Cur porta hodie tam sero aperitur?
    Why is the gate being opened so late today?

When that question becomes dependent on scit (knows), Latin changes the verb to the subjunctive:

  • scit cur ... aperiatur
    knows why ... is being opened

So cur still means why, but the whole clause now functions as the object of scit.


What form is aperiatur?

Aperiatur is:

  • present
  • subjunctive
  • passive
  • third person singular

from the verb aperire = to open

So it means:

  • may be opened
  • or in this sentence more naturally, is being opened

Because it is passive, porta is the thing being opened.


Why is porta nominative?

Because porta is the subject of the passive verb aperiatur.

In English, we say:

  • the gate is being opened

Here the gate is the grammatical subject, even though it is receiving the action.

So in Latin:

  • porta = nominative singular, the gate
  • aperiatur = is being opened

If the sentence were active, the gate would be the object instead.


Why is it sero and not sera?

Because sero here is an adverb, not an adjective.

  • serus, sera, serum = late as an adjective
  • sero = late as an adverb

In this sentence, it describes when the opening happens:

  • tam sero = so late

It is not describing porta; it is modifying the verb aperiatur.


What does tam sero mean exactly?

Tam means so, and sero means late.

Together:

  • tam sero = so late

It can express surprise, complaint, or emphasis:

  • Why is the gate being opened so late today?

Latin often uses tam to intensify an adjective or adverb.


Does porta mean door or gate?

It can mean either, depending on context, but gate is often the most natural meaning for porta, especially for a large entrance, city gate, or outer door.

So a learner should remember:

  • porta = gate, door, or large entranceway

The exact English word depends on the situation.


Why is the word order so different from English?

Latin word order is much freer than English word order because Latin uses endings to show grammatical relationships.

English depends heavily on order:

  • Does anyone know why the gate is being opened so late today?

Latin can arrange words more flexibly:

  • Num quisquam scit cur porta hodie tam sero aperiatur?

A few points:

  • num often comes near the beginning
  • scit can appear early because it governs the indirect question
  • cur introduces the subordinate clause
  • hodie and tam sero are placed naturally for emphasis and flow
  • aperiatur often comes at the end of its clause

So the Latin order is not random; it is just less rigid than English.


Is hodie part of the main question or part of the cur clause?

It belongs with the cur clause:

  • cur porta hodie tam sero aperiatur
    why the gate is being opened so late today

It tells us when the opening is happening, so it modifies aperiatur, not scit.

In other words, the sentence is not mainly asking Does anyone know today...?
It is asking Does anyone know why the gate is opened so late today?


Could Latin have used aperitur instead of aperiatur?

Not in standard classical grammar for this sentence.

  • Cur porta hodie tam sero aperitur? = direct question
  • Scit cur porta hodie tam sero aperiatur = indirect question

In an indirect question after scit, Latin normally uses the subjunctive. So aperiatur is the expected form.

Using aperitur here would go against the usual classical rule for indirect questions.


What is the overall structure of the sentence?

A helpful way to divide it is:

  • Num = introduces the yes/no question, with an expected no
  • quisquam = anyone
  • scit = knows
  • cur = why
  • porta = the gate
  • hodie = today
  • tam sero = so late
  • aperiatur = is being opened / may be opened

So the sentence is:

  • a main yes/no question
  • containing an indirect question

That makes it a very useful example of how Latin combines clause types.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
Your avatar
What's the best way to learn Latin grammar?
Latin grammar becomes intuitive with practice. Focus on understanding the core patterns first — how sentences are structured, how verbs change form, and how words relate to each other. Our course breaks these concepts into small lessons so you can build understanding step by step.

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Latin

Master Latin — from Num quisquam scit cur porta hodie tam sero aperiatur to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • AI tutor to answer your grammar questions