Domina rogat utrum aurifex catenae nitidae pretium minuere possit.

Questions & Answers about Domina rogat utrum aurifex catenae nitidae pretium minuere possit.

Why is utrum used here?

Utrum introduces an indirect yes/no question, so here it means whether.

  • Domina rogat = The lady asks
  • utrum ... possit = whether ... can / might be able to

In Latin, after verbs like rogat (asks), nescit (does not know), videt (sees), and similar verbs, Latin often uses utrum to introduce whether-clauses.

You may also see other ways to introduce this kind of question, such as -ne or num, but utrum is a very standard and clear choice.

Why is possit subjunctive instead of potest?

Because the clause introduced by utrum is an indirect question, and Latin normally puts the verb of an indirect question in the subjunctive.

So:

  • potest = he can in a direct statement/question
  • possit = he can / may be able to in an indirect question

Compare:

  • Direct question: Aurifex pretium minuere potest? = Can the goldsmith lower the price?
  • Indirect question: Domina rogat utrum aurifex pretium minuere possit. = The lady asks whether the goldsmith can lower the price.

So the subjunctive here is not mainly making it vague or hypothetical; it is there because Latin grammar requires it in indirect questions.

Why is minuere an infinitive?

Because it depends on possit.

Latin often uses a complementary infinitive after verbs of being able, wanting, daring, beginning, and so on. Here:

  • possit = is able / can
  • minuere = to lower / to reduce

Together, minuere possit means can lower.

This is similar to English:

  • can lower
  • is able to lower

So minuere is not a separate action floating on its own; it completes the meaning of possit.

What case is aurifex, and what is it doing in the sentence?

Aurifex is nominative singular, and it is the subject of possit.

So in the indirect question:

  • aurifex = the goldsmith
  • possit = can
  • minuere = lower
  • pretium = the price

That gives: whether the goldsmith can lower the price

Even though domina is the subject of rogat, the indirect question has its own subject, aurifex.

Why are catenae nitidae in the genitive?

They are in the genitive singular because they depend on pretium.

  • pretium = price
  • catenae nitidae = of the shiny necklace

So the phrase means:

  • pretium catenae nitidae = the price of the shiny necklace

This is a very common Latin use of the genitive: showing possession or close relation, often translated with of in English.

Why is it catenae nitidae and not catenam nitidam?

Because the sentence is talking about the price of the necklace, not saying that the goldsmith is lowering the necklace itself.

The thing directly affected by minuere is pretium, so pretium is the accusative object of minuere.

Meanwhile, catenae nitidae tells us which price:

  • not just a price
  • but the price of the shiny necklace

So:

  • pretium = accusative, because it is what is being lowered
  • catenae nitidae = genitive, because it describes whose/what price it is

If Latin had catenam nitidam, that would suggest the necklace itself was the direct object.

What does nitidae agree with?

Nitidae agrees with catenae.

Both are:

  • genitive singular
  • feminine

So:

  • catenae = of the necklace
  • nitidae = shiny / bright, describing the necklace

This agreement is one of the key things to watch in Latin: adjectives agree with the nouns they describe in gender, number, and case.

How do we know catenae is genitive singular and not something else?

Formally, catenae can have more than one possible meaning, because first-declension endings overlap. It could be:

  • genitive singular
  • dative singular
  • nominative plural
  • vocative plural

But in this sentence, the syntax makes genitive singular the right choice.

Why?

Because it sits naturally with pretium:

  • pretium catenae nitidae = the price of the shiny necklace

That is a standard noun + genitive pattern. The other possibilities do not fit the sentence nearly as well.

So this is a good example of how Latin readers often use both endings and context together.

Why is there no an after utrum?

Because an is usually added when there is a second alternative.

For example:

  • utrum hoc an illud = whether this or that

But here there is only one issue being asked about:

  • whether the goldsmith can lower the price

So Latin can simply use utrum by itself.

In English, this is like saying whether without adding an explicit or not.

Could Latin leave out utrum here?

Sometimes Latin can omit an introductory word in indirect questions, but with a yes/no indirect question, using utrum is very common and helpful.

It clearly marks the clause as whether ... rather than some other kind of subordinate clause.

So while learners should know that Latin can sometimes be more flexible, in this sentence utrum is doing a useful job by making the structure very clear.

Why is the word order different from normal English word order?

Latin word order is much more flexible than English word order because Latin uses endings to show the grammatical role of each word.

So Latin does not need to rely on position as heavily as English does.

This sentence is arranged as:

  • Domina = subject of the main verb
  • rogat = main verb
  • utrum = introduces the indirect question
  • aurifex = subject of the indirect question
  • catenae nitidae = genitive phrase modifying pretium
  • pretium = object of minuere
  • minuere = infinitive
  • possit = verb of the indirect question, placed at the end

Putting the finite verb at or near the end of a subordinate clause is very common in Latin prose.

Why is possit present subjunctive and not imperfect subjunctive?

Because of sequence of tenses.

The main verb is rogat, which is a present tense, so it is a primary tense. In an indirect question after a primary tense, Latin normally uses the present subjunctive for action that is contemporaneous with the main verb.

So:

  • rogat ... possit = she asks whether he can

If the main verb were past, Latin would normally shift to the imperfect subjunctive:

  • Domina rogavit utrum aurifex pretium minuere posset.
  • The lady asked whether the goldsmith could lower the price.

So possit fits the tense of the main verb very naturally.

Is pretium minuere a common Latin expression?

Yes. Pretium minuere is a very natural way to say to lower the price or to reduce the price.

  • pretium = price
  • minuere = to lessen, reduce, lower

So the phrase works much like English reduce the price.

It is useful to learn it as a chunk, because it is a common kind of commercial expression.

What kind of noun is aurifex?

Aurifex is a third-declension noun, even though its meaning is masculine here: goldsmith.

Its nominative singular is aurifex. A learner may expect many masculine job words to look second-declension, but Latin has plenty of masculine third-declension nouns too.

So the important thing is not to assume declension from meaning alone. The form aurifex belongs to the third declension.

Is domina doing the asking directly to the goldsmith?

The Latin sentence itself does not explicitly say to whom she is asking. It only says that the lady asks whether the goldsmith can lower the price of the shiny necklace.

So grammatically, all we know is:

  • domina = the one asking
  • aurifex = the one whose ability is being questioned

The sentence could mean she is asking the goldsmith directly, or asking someone else about him, depending on context. Latin here leaves that unstated.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
What's the best way to learn Latin grammar?
Latin grammar becomes intuitive with practice. Focus on understanding the core patterns first — how sentences are structured, how verbs change form, and how words relate to each other. Our course breaks these concepts into small lessons so you can build understanding step by step.

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Latin

Master Latin — from Domina rogat utrum aurifex catenae nitidae pretium minuere possit to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • AI tutor to answer your grammar questions