Breakdown of Nescio cur frater tam sero surgat; soror enim ad scholam prima venire solet.
Questions & Answers about Nescio cur frater tam sero surgat; soror enim ad scholam prima venire solet.
Why is surgat in the subjunctive instead of surgit?
Because cur frater tam sero surgat is an indirect question after nescio (I do not know).
In Latin, indirect questions normally use the subjunctive, even when English uses an ordinary indicative verb:
- Cur surgit? = Why is he getting up? / Why does he get up?
- Nescio cur surgat. = I do not know why he is getting up / gets up.
So surgat does not mean may get up here. It is simply the normal mood for an indirect question.
What exactly does cur mean here?
Cur means why.
It introduces the indirect question:
- Nescio cur... = I do not know why...
This is very common in Latin. Other question words can work the same way in indirect questions, such as quis (who), quid (what), ubi (where), and so on.
What is the subject of surgat?
The subject is frater (brother).
So the clause breaks down like this:
- frater = the brother
- tam sero = so late
- surgat = gets up / is getting up
Together: why the brother gets up so late.
What does tam sero mean, and what kind of word is sero?
Tam sero means so late.
- tam = so
- sero = late
Here sero is an adverb, not an adjective. It describes the action surgat:
- surgat = gets up
- tam sero surgat = gets up so late
A learner might expect something like an adjective form, but in Latin sero is the normal adverb.
Why is enim in the second clause, and what does it mean?
Enim means something like for, indeed, or you see.
It is a postpositive word, which means it usually comes second in its clause, not first. So Latin prefers:
- soror enim...
rather than putting enim at the very beginning.
In this sentence, it gives a reason or explanation for the speaker’s surprise:
- I do not know why my brother gets up so late; for my sister usually arrives at school first.
Why is venire an infinitive?
Because it depends on solet.
Soleo, solere means to be accustomed, to be in the habit of, or more naturally in English, to usually do something. It is commonly followed by an infinitive:
- venire solet = she usually comes / she is accustomed to come
So:
- soror... venire solet = the sister usually comes
More literally, is accustomed to come.
What does solet mean exactly?
Solet is the 3rd person singular present of soleo.
Its basic sense is:
- is accustomed
- usually
- tends to
So venire solet can be translated in a few natural ways:
- she usually comes
- she is accustomed to come
- she tends to come
In this sentence, the idea is habitual action.
Why is prima feminine singular, and what is it doing grammatically?
Prima agrees with soror, which is feminine singular nominative.
- soror = feminine singular nominative
- prima = feminine singular nominative
It means first, and it is used predicatively: the sister comes first.
So:
- soror prima venire solet = the sister usually comes first
It is not directly modifying scholam. It goes with soror.
Does prima mean the first girl or first in the sense of arriving before others?
Here it means first in the sense of arriving before others.
So prima venire means:
- to come first
- to arrive first
It is not just identifying her as the first sister or the first one in a list. The context is about who gets to school earliest.
Why is it ad scholam and not some other preposition?
Ad with the accusative often means to or toward a place.
So:
- ad scholam = to school
This expresses motion toward the school. Since venire involves coming, ad is very natural.
A learner might wonder whether Latin always omits a preposition as English sometimes does in go to school or come to school, but Latin often uses ad + accusative for this idea.
Why is there no word for her or his before brother and sister?
Latin often does not use possessive words like my, his, or her unless they are needed for emphasis or clarity.
So frater and soror by themselves can simply mean:
- brother
- sister
In context, they often mean his brother, my brother, her sister, and so on, depending on who is speaking and what has already been established.
Latin is often less explicit than English about possession when the relationship is obvious.
Why is nescio present tense?
Nescio is present tense because the speaker is saying I do not know right now.
The sentence is framed from the speaker’s present point of view:
- Nescio = I do not know
- surgat = the verb inside the indirect question
- solet = usually / is accustomed
So the whole sentence describes a present lack of knowledge and a habitual contrast.
Can surgat be translated as gets up even though it is subjunctive?
Yes. In this kind of sentence, that is exactly how it is often translated.
Because surgat is inside an indirect question, the subjunctive is required by Latin grammar, but English does not usually show that difference. So a natural translation is:
- I do not know why my brother gets up so late...
rather than something like may get up.
This is an important point: in indirect questions, the Latin subjunctive often has no special modal force in English.
What is the relationship between the two halves of the sentence?
The second half explains or supports the first.
- Nescio cur frater tam sero surgat = the speaker does not understand the brother’s late rising.
- soror enim ad scholam prima venire solet = after all, the sister usually gets to school first.
The idea seems to be that the brother’s lateness is surprising, especially when compared with the sister’s habit of arriving first. The semicolon helps mark this close but distinct relationship.
Is there anything especially idiomatic about prima venire solet?
Yes: it is a very natural Latin way to express she usually comes first.
The structure is:
- prima = first
- venire = to come
- solet = usually does / is accustomed to do
So rather than using a separate adverb like usually and another phrase for arrives first, Latin simply says:
- prima venire solet
This is compact and idiomatic Latin.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Nescio cur frater tam sero surgat; soror enim ad scholam prima venire solet to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions