Questions & Answers about A diák látja őket a kertben.
- Őket = “them” (personal pronoun), typically for people (sometimes for animals you care about).
- Azokat = “those (ones)” (demonstrative), can refer to things or people.
If you’ve been talking about specific people, őket is natural. If you mean “those ones (over there/just mentioned),” especially things, azokat fits.
It’s the 3rd person singular definite ending. Rough breakdown:
- lát = verb stem “see”
- -ja = he/she/it … [definite object]
All are grammatical, but word order expresses information structure (focus) in Hungarian:
- A diák látja őket a kertben. Neutral/declarative feel.
- A diák a kertben látja őket. Slight emphasis on location; common neutral variant.
- A diák őket látja a kertben. Focus on őket (“It’s them that the student sees…”).
- A kertben látja őket a diák. Focus on A kertben (“In the garden is where the student sees them.”).
The focused element sits right before the verb.
-ban/-ben is the inessive case “in.” The choice depends on vowel harmony:
- Back vowels → -ban
- Front vowels → -ben
Kert has front vowels (e), so it takes -ben: kertben = “in the garden.”
- kertben = “in the garden” (location; static)
- kertbe = “into the garden” (movement towards; illative)
Yes, but it changes the meaning:
- a kertben = “in the garden” (specific garden)
- kertben = “in a garden / in gardens (in general)” (non-specific or habitual context)
- látja is often pronounced like “látya” because the t + j cluster assimilates to a sound close to Hungarian ty.
- kertben is commonly pronounced like “kerdben” due to voicing assimilation (t becomes d before b).
- Stress is always on the first syllable: A DIÁK LÁT-ja Ő-ket A KERT-ben.
With a plural subject you mark the verb as 3rd person plural definite:
A diákok látják őket a kertben. (“The students see them in the garden.”)
Only when the object isn’t definite. For example:
- A diák lát embereket a kertben. (“The student sees people in the garden.”) — indefinite object → lát
- A diák látja az embereket a kertben. (“The student sees the people in the garden.”) — definite object → látja
Put nem right before the verb (and it precedes any focused element if present):
- A diák nem látja őket a kertben. (“The student doesn’t see them in the garden.”)
- With focus: A diák nem őket látja a kertben. (“It’s not them that the student sees in the garden.”)
No. Definite vs. indefinite is about reference, not animacy. Diák is just “student.” It becomes definite with the article/demonstrative/possessor, etc.:
- egy diák = “a student” (indefinite)
- a diák = “the student” (definite)
- az a diák = “that student” (definite)
- a diák látja… vs. egy diák lát… will affect the verb form only if they are objects; here they’re subjects, so the verb’s definiteness depends on the object (őket).
Hungarian lát is plain “see.” To express ability, you’d add tud:
A diák látja őket a kertben. = “The student sees them…”
A diák tudja őket látni a kertben. = “The student is able to see them in the garden.” (More natural: A diák látni tudja őket a kertben.)