Breakdown of A melléklet a kérelemben van.
Questions & Answers about A melléklet a kérelemben van.
Why are there two a words in A melléklet a kérelemben van?
Because a is the Hungarian definite article, meaning the.
So the sentence breaks down like this:
- a melléklet = the attachment / the appendix / the enclosure
- a kérelemben = in the application / in the request
Hungarian uses the definite article very regularly, so if both nouns are definite, both can take a.
Also:
- a is used before consonant sounds
- az is used before vowel sounds
So you get:
- a melléklet
- a kérelem but
- az irat
What does kérelemben mean, and what is the -ben ending?
Kérelemben consists of:
- kérelem = application, request, petition
- -ben = in
So:
- kérelemben = in the application/request
Hungarian often expresses meanings like in, on, under, from, to, etc. with endings attached directly to the noun rather than with separate prepositions.
Compare:
- házban = in the house
- dobozban = in the box
- kérelemben = in the application
This kind of ending is called a case ending. Here, -ban/-ben is the ending for in.
Why is it -ben and not -ban?
This is because of vowel harmony, a very important feature of Hungarian.
The ending for in has two forms:
- -ban
- -ben
Which one you use depends on the vowels in the word.
- kérelem contains front vowels, so it takes -ben
- for a back-vowel word, you would usually use -ban
Examples:
- kertben = in the garden
- székben = in the chair
- házban = in the house
- szobában = in the room
So kérelemben is the expected harmonic form.
Why is the ending attached to the noun instead of using a separate word for in?
Because Hungarian is an agglutinative language. That means grammatical meanings are often shown by adding endings directly to words.
In English, you say:
- in the application
In Hungarian, the same idea is usually expressed as:
- a kérelemben
So instead of a separate preposition like in, Hungarian uses a noun ending.
This is very normal in Hungarian:
- asztalon = on the table
- házból = out of the house
- iskolába = into the school
- kérelemben = in the application
Why is van used here? I thought Hungarian often leaves out is/are in the present tense.
That's a very common and very good question.
Hungarian often omits van in the present tense in sentences like:
- A melléklet fontos. = The attachment is important.
- A kérelem kész. = The application is ready.
But in sentences showing location or existence, van is normally used:
- A melléklet a kérelemben van. = The attachment is in the application.
- A könyv az asztalon van. = The book is on the table.
So the rule of thumb is:
- with identification or description, 3rd person present van is often omitted
- with location/existence, van is usually kept
That is why van appears here.
What is the basic word order of this sentence?
The basic structure is:
- A melléklet = topic / what we are talking about
- a kérelemben = location
- van = is
So:
- A melléklet a kérelemben van.
- literally: The attachment in the application is.
This is normal Hungarian word order for a neutral statement.
Hungarian word order is flexible, but changes in order often change emphasis rather than basic meaning.
For example:
- A melléklet a kérelemben van. = neutral: The attachment is in the application.
- A kérelemben van a melléklet. = emphasis more on where it is
- A melléklet van a kérelemben. = emphasis more on the attachment as the thing that is there
So the original sentence is a straightforward, neutral version.
What exactly does melléklet mean here?
Melléklet can mean things like:
- attachment
- appendix
- enclosure
- annex
The exact English word depends on context.
For example:
- in a document or official paperwork context, melléklet often means attachment or enclosure
- in a book or formal text, it might mean appendix
- in legal or administrative language, it can mean annex
So in this sentence, it most likely refers to some document or item included with the application/request.
What is the difference between kérelemben and kérelembe?
This is the difference between in and into.
- -ban/-ben = in
- -ba/-be = into
So:
- a kérelemben van = it is in the application
- a kérelembe teszi = he/she puts it into the application
Examples:
- A levél a dobozban van. = The letter is in the box.
- A levelet a dobozba teszi. = He/she puts the letter into the box.
In your sentence, the meaning is location, not movement, so -ben is correct.
Could this sentence be translated in more than one way in English?
Yes. Even if the general meaning is already known, there can be a few natural English translations depending on context.
Possible translations include:
- The attachment is in the application.
- The enclosure is in the application.
- The appendix is in the application.
- The annex is in the application.
Also, kérelem can mean:
- application
- request
- sometimes petition, depending on context
So another possible translation could be:
- The attachment is in the request.
The grammar stays the same; only the best vocabulary choice changes with context.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning HungarianMaster Hungarian — from A melléklet a kérelemben van to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions