Breakdown of Attól függően, hogy melyikkel látok jobban, az optikus segít választani.
Questions & Answers about Attól függően, hogy melyikkel látok jobban, az optikus segít választani.
What does attól függően mean?
It is a fixed expression meaning depending on.
- attól = on that / from that
- függően comes from függ = to depend
So attól függően introduces the basis or condition for something else: depending on ...
How is attól függően, hogy... different from attól függ, hogy...?
They are related, but not used in quite the same way.
- Attól függ, hogy... = It depends on whether/how...
- Attól függően, hogy... = Depending on whether/how...
So attól függ, hogy... can be the main statement by itself, while attól függően, hogy... works more like an introductory phrase attached to another clause.
In your sentence, the main clause is az optikus segít választani.
Why is there a hogy after attól függően?
Because hogy introduces the subordinate clause that explains what the dependence is based on.
So:
- attól függően = depending on
- hogy melyikkel látok jobban = which one I see better with
This pattern is very common in Hungarian: attól függően, hogy...
What does melyikkel mean exactly?
Melyik means which one.
Here it has the instrumental/comitative ending -val / -vel, which often means with. So:
- melyik = which one
- melyikkel = with which one
In context, it means something like with which one or through which one, probably referring to lenses, glasses, or options the optician is showing.
Why does melyik + -vel become melyikkel?
Because of a very common sound/spelling change with -val / -vel.
When this suffix is added to a word ending in a consonant, the v often assimilates to the final consonant, and that consonant gets doubled in spelling.
So:
- melyik + vel becomes melyikkel
The same kind of thing happens in words like:
- kéz + vel → kézzel
- ablak + val → ablakkal
Why is it látok, not látom?
Because Hungarian uses indefinite and definite verb conjugation, and here there is no definite direct object.
- látok = indefinite
- látom = definite
In this sentence, melyikkel is not a direct object. It means with which one, so it is an instrumental phrase, not the thing being directly seen. That is why látok is correct.
Why is it jobban, not jobb?
Because jobban is the adverb form, and it modifies the verb látok.
- jobb = better as an adjective
- jobban = better as an adverb
So:
- jobb szemüveg = better glasses
- jobban látok = I see better
Since the sentence is talking about how I see, Hungarian uses jobban.
What does az optikus segít választani mean literally?
Literally, it means the optician helps to choose.
Hungarian often uses:
- segít + infinitive
So:
- segít választani = helps choose / helps to choose
In natural English, you would usually say the optician helps me choose.
Where is me in helps me choose?
It is omitted because Hungarian often leaves out things that are clear from context.
So az optikus segít választani can naturally mean:
- the optician helps me choose
- or more literally, the optician helps with choosing
If you wanted to say me explicitly, you could add nekem:
- Az optikus segít nekem választani.
Why is there no object after választani? Choose what?
Because Hungarian often omits the object if it is obvious from the situation.
Here, the missing object is probably something like:
- glasses
- lenses
- frames
- the better option
So segít választani is perfectly natural when both speakers already know what is being chosen.
Why does the sentence start with the depending on... part?
Because Hungarian word order is flexible, and the first part often gives the background, condition, or frame for the main statement.
So this order:
- Attól függően, hogy melyikkel látok jobban, az optikus segít választani.
puts the condition first: depending on which one I see better with...
That is a very natural way to structure the sentence.
Why is it az optikus and not egy optikus?
Because az optikus means the optician, a specific one known in the situation.
- az optikus = the optician
- egy optikus = an optician / a certain optician
In this sentence, it sounds like the speaker is talking about the optician they are currently dealing with, so az optikus is the natural choice.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning HungarianMaster Hungarian — from Attól függően, hogy melyikkel látok jobban, az optikus segít választani to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions