Breakdown of Attól függően, hogy van-e asztigmia, másik próbalencsét választunk.
Questions & Answers about Attól függően, hogy van-e asztigmia, másik próbalencsét választunk.
What does Attól függően, hogy... mean as a whole?
It is a common Hungarian way to say depending on whether... or more generally depending on....
In this sentence, Attól függően, hogy van-e asztigmia... means:
depending on whether there is astigmatism...
So this opening part sets up the condition or factor that the decision depends on.
What exactly is attól here?
Attól comes from az meaning that, plus the ending -tól/-től, which often means from.
So literally, attól függően is something like depending on that.
You do not need to translate it word for word every time, though. In practice, attól függően works as part of a fixed expression meaning depending on.
Also, the form is attól, not aztól, because of sound changes in Hungarian spelling and pronunciation.
What is függően? Is it a normal verb form?
Függően comes from the verb függ, meaning to depend or to hang.
Here it is a participial form, and in modern Hungarian it is most often seen in the fixed expression attól függően.
So even though it comes from a verb, many learners are best off understanding attól függően as a single unit meaning depending on rather than trying to build it from scratch every time.
Why is hogy used here?
Hogy introduces a subordinate clause.
After attól függően, Hungarian often uses hogy when what follows is a full clause rather than just a noun.
So:
- Attól függően, hogy van-e asztigmia... = Depending on whether there is astigmatism...
Without hogy, the structure would feel incomplete here.
Why is it van-e with a hyphen? What does -e mean?
The -e is a question particle used in Hungarian yes-no questions and embedded whether clauses.
So:
- van = is / there is
- van-e = is there? / whether there is
In standard spelling, -e is attached to the verb with a hyphen, so van-e is correct.
In this sentence, it does not make the whole sentence a direct question. Instead, it creates an embedded whether meaning:
whether there is astigmatism
Why is it van-e asztigmia and not van asztigmia-e?
Because -e attaches to the finite verb, not to the noun.
So the normal form is:
- van-e asztigmia
not:
- van asztigmia-e
That second version is not standard Hungarian.
A good rule for learners is: in this kind of structure, attach -e to the verb.
Why is there no article before asztigmia?
Hungarian often leaves out the article in this kind of existential or diagnostic wording.
So van asztigmia is literally there is astigmatism, and in context it can also mean the patient has astigmatism.
This is natural Hungarian.
If you wanted a more explicitly possessive version, Hungarian could also say something like asztigmiája van, meaning he/she has astigmatism. But the sentence you have uses a more impersonal, clinical style.
Why does próbalencse become próbalencsét?
Because it is the direct object of the verb választunk meaning we choose.
Hungarian marks direct objects with the accusative ending -t.
So:
- próbalencse = trial lens
- próbalencsét = trial lens as a direct object
Also, nouns ending in -a or -e often lengthen that final vowel before certain endings:
- próbalencse → próbalencsét
This is a very common pattern in Hungarian.
Why is it másik próbalencsét without a or egy?
Másik can mean another or a different and can appear without an article.
So:
- másik próbalencsét = another / a different trial lens
This keeps the object indefinite.
If you said:
- a másik próbalencsét, that would mean the other trial lens, a specific one
- egy másik próbalencsét is also possible, but often unnecessary
So the version in your sentence is completely natural.
Why is the verb választunk and not választjuk?
This is because Hungarian has two main verb conjugation patterns:
Here the object is indefinite:
- másik próbalencsét = another / a different trial lens
So Hungarian uses the indefinite form:
- választunk = we choose
If the object were definite, Hungarian would use the definite conjugation:
- a másik próbalencsét választjuk = we choose the other trial lens
This is a very important grammar point in Hungarian.
Why is the object before the verb in másik próbalencsét választunk?
Hungarian word order is much freer than English word order.
English strongly prefers:
- we choose a different trial lens
Hungarian can place the object before the verb quite naturally:
- másik próbalencsét választunk
This is especially common with indefinite objects and in neutral, matter-of-fact statements.
So you should not assume that Hungarian always follows English-style subject + verb + object order. Word order in Hungarian is influenced a lot by information structure, emphasis, and sentence rhythm.
What person and tense is választunk?
Választunk is:
- present tense
- first person plural
So literally it means we choose.
In medical or professional language, Hungarian often uses we in a practical, institutional, or professional sense, just like English sometimes does. It does not necessarily mean that several people are physically doing the action together.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning HungarianMaster Hungarian — from Attól függően, hogy van-e asztigmia, másik próbalencsét választunk to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions