Questions & Answers about Karc van a vázán.
The sentence breaks down like this:
- karc = scratch
- van = is / there is
- a vázán = on the vase
So the sentence is an existential/location sentence: it says that a scratch exists on the vase.
A very literal gloss would be something like:
- scratch is on-the-vase
But the natural English meaning is There is a scratch on the vase.
That is a very common question, and the short answer is:
Hungarian often drops the present-tense copula in 3rd person when the sentence is about identity or description, but not when the sentence expresses existence or location.
For example:
- A váza szép. = The vase is beautiful.
- Ez egy váza. = This is a vase.
In those, there is no van.
But in sentences like these, van stays:
- A váza az asztalon van. = The vase is on the table.
- Karc van a vázán. = There is a scratch on the vase.
So here van is needed because the sentence says that something exists in a particular place.