Soll ich eins essen?

Should I eat one?

Breakdown of Soll ich eins essen?

• essen: to eat
• ich: I
• sollen: should
• eins: one

Questions & Answers about Soll ich eins essen?

Why does soll come at the very beginning of the sentence, and why does ich follow it?

This is a yes/no question in German. In such questions, the conjugated verb (here soll, the 3rd‑person singular form of sollen) takes the first position, and the subject (ich) immediately follows. If this were a statement, you’d say Ich soll eins essen.

What does the modal verb sollen mean in Soll ich eins essen?

Sollen expresses advice, recommendation, or obligation, similar to should in English. So Soll ich eins essen? literally means “Should I eat one?”

Why is the infinitive essen placed at the end of the sentence?

In German, when you use a modal verb like sollen, the main verb remains in its infinitive form and moves to the end of the clause. That’s why essen appears at the very end.

What kind of word is eins, and why is it used here instead of ein?

Eins is the numeral pronoun for one (of them). It stands alone and replaces the noun plus article when you want one piece of something without restating the noun. Ein is an indefinite article and must accompany a noun (or be declined as einen, eine, etc.), but eins works by itself.

Is eins in the accusative case, and does it change its form?

Yes, eins functions as the direct object of essen, so it’s in the accusative case. However, numeral pronouns like eins do not decline; they keep the same form in both nominative and accusative.

Could you use es or an indefinite pronoun like einen/eine instead of eins, and what’s the difference?

You could say Soll ich es essen? to mean “Should I eat it?” when referring to a known neuter noun (es replaces a specific item). If the noun has gender and you drop the noun, use its matching indefinite pronoun:

• einen for masculine (e.g. Soll ich einen essen? if you mean one Keks),
• eine for feminine,
• ein (accusative) for neuter.

How might I respond to Soll ich eins essen? in German?

For yes, you could say:

• Ja, iss eins. (informal imperative)
• Ja, du solltest eins essen. (more formal)

For no, you might say:

• Nein, iss keins. (“keins” = “none”)
• Nein, danke, ich bin satt. (“No, thanks, I’m full.”)