Breakdown of Pas je starý, je však stále platný.
Questions & Answers about Pas je starý, je však stále platný.
Why does pas mean passport here? I thought it could also mean belt or even strip.
Yes, pas can have more than one meaning in Czech, just like some English words do.
In this sentence, pas means passport. That is clear from the adjective platný (valid), because documents like passports, tickets, and IDs are commonly described as platný / neplatný (valid / invalid).
So although pas can mean other things in other contexts, here the surrounding words make passport the natural interpretation.
What gender is pas, and how do we know?
Why is je used twice?
Because the sentence has two separate clauses, and each clause has its own verb:
- Pas je starý = The passport is old
- je však stále platný = however, it is still valid
In Czech, if you have two coordinated clauses like this, it is completely normal to repeat the verb. English does the same in a full version:
- The passport is old, but it is still valid.
So the second je is not redundant; it belongs to the second clause.
Why is there no word for it in the second clause?
Czech often omits subject pronouns when they are already clear from context. This is very common.
In English, you usually need:
- it is still valid
But in Czech, once pas has already been mentioned, you do not need to repeat a pronoun like on (he/it, for masculine nouns). So Czech simply says:
- je však stále platný
The subject is understood to be pas.
If you did say on, it would usually sound more emphatic or contrastive than necessary here.
What does však mean here?
How is však different from ale?
Both can express contrast, but they are not used in exactly the same way.
- ale usually corresponds directly to but
- však often feels a bit more like however / nevertheless
In many sentences they can be close in meaning:
- Pas je starý, ale stále platný.
- Pas je starý, je však stále platný.
The version with však is a little more formal or written in tone. It also often appears inside the clause rather than at the very beginning.
So for learners:
- use ale for a simple everyday but
- learn to recognize však as a slightly more literary or formal contrast word
Why is však placed after je instead of at the beginning?
This is a typical Czech word-order pattern.
Však is one of those words that often stands in an unstressed, non-initial position, frequently near the beginning of the clause but not necessarily as the first word. So:
- je však stále platný
sounds natural.
Czech word order is more flexible than English word order, but it is not random. Small connecting words like však often prefer certain positions.
You may also see other arrangements in real Czech, but this one is very normal and idiomatic.
What does stále mean exactly?
Why do starý and platný both end in -ý?
Because they agree with pas.
In Czech, adjectives must agree with the noun in:
- gender
- number
- case
Here the noun is:
- pas = masculine inanimate
- singular
- nominative
So the adjectives also appear in the masculine singular nominative form:
- starý
- platný
This is one of the most important grammar patterns in Czech: adjective-noun agreement.
Is platný the normal word for valid with documents?
Yes. Platný is the standard and very common word for valid when talking about documents, tickets, laws, contracts, and similar things.
Examples:
- platný pas = valid passport
- platná jízdenka = valid ticket
- platný občanský průkaz = valid ID card
Its opposite is:
- neplatný = invalid / no longer valid
So stále platný is a very natural phrase.
Could I also say Pas je starý, ale stále platný?
Yes, absolutely. That would be a very natural sentence too.
Compare:
- Pas je starý, ale stále platný.
- Pas je starý, je však stále platný.
The first is a bit simpler and more conversational. The second sounds slightly more formal or stylistically polished.
So both are correct; they just have a slightly different feel.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CzechMaster Czech — from Pas je starý, je však stále platný to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions