Breakdown of Trebalo bi pomesti blagovaonicu prije večere.
Questions & Answers about Trebalo bi pomesti blagovaonicu prije večere.
What does trebalo bi mean here?
Trebalo bi means should or ought to.
In this sentence, it gives a recommendation or mild obligation:
- Trebalo bi pomesti blagovaonicu prije večere.
= The dining room should be swept before dinner.
This is a very common Croatian way to express what would be advisable or appropriate.
Why is it trebalo bi and not something like trebao bi?
Because this is an impersonal construction.
When Croatian uses trebati in the sense of it is necessary / one should, it often appears in the neuter singular form:
- treba = it is necessary / should
- trebalo bi = it should / one should
So trebalo here does not refer to a masculine person or thing. It is the default neuter form used in impersonal statements.
Compare:
- Trebao bih pomesti blagovaonicu. = I should sweep the dining room.
Here trebao agrees with I (masculine speaker). - Trebalo bi pomesti blagovaonicu. = The dining room should be swept / One should sweep the dining room.
No specific person is named.
What exactly is bi doing in trebalo bi?
Bi is a marker of the conditional mood.
It helps create the meaning of:
- would
- should
- ought to
So:
- treba = need(s) to / it is necessary
- trebalo bi = should / ought to / it would be good to
This makes the sentence softer and less direct than a plain statement of necessity.
What does pomesti mean?
Pomesti means to sweep.
More specifically, it is a perfective infinitive, so it suggests a completed action: to sweep something up / to get the sweeping done.
Croatian often has verb pairs like this:
- mesti = to be sweeping / to sweep in a more general or ongoing sense (imperfective)
- pomesti = to sweep up, to sweep completely (perfective)
In this sentence, the perfective verb fits well because the idea is to complete the task before dinner.
Why is pomesti in the infinitive?
Because after trebalo bi, Croatian commonly uses an infinitive to express the action that should be done.
Structure:
- trebalo bi + infinitive
So:
- trebalo bi pomesti = should sweep / should be swept
This is very similar to English should + verb.
Why is it blagovaonicu and not blagovaonica?
Because blagovaonicu is the accusative singular, used here for the direct object of the verb pomesti.
Base form:
- blagovaonica = dining room
In the sentence, the dining room is the thing being swept, so it goes into the accusative:
- pomesti blagovaonicu = to sweep the dining room
This is a feminine noun ending in -a, so:
- nominative singular: blagovaonica
- accusative singular: blagovaonicu
What case is večere, and why?
Večere is in the genitive singular.
That is because the preposition prije (before) requires the genitive:
- prije večere = before dinner
So:
- nominative: večera = dinner
- genitive: večere
This is a very common pattern in Croatian:
- prije ručka = before lunch
- prije sastanka = before the meeting
- prije večere = before dinner
Can prije večere mean both before dinner and before the evening meal starts?
Yes, in normal usage it usually just means before dinner in the practical sense: before the evening meal happens or before people sit down to eat.
Like in English, the exact timing depends on context. It does not usually need a more precise explanation unless the situation requires it.
Is this sentence active or passive in meaning?
Grammatically, it uses an impersonal construction, but in meaning it often feels close to English passive:
- Trebalo bi pomesti blagovaonicu. = The dining room should be swept. = Someone should sweep the dining room.
Croatian does not need a true passive form here. The impersonal trebalo bi + infinitive is very natural.
Could I also say Treba pomesti blagovaonicu prije večere?
Yes. That would also be natural.
The difference is roughly:
- Treba pomesti blagovaonicu prije večere.
= It is necessary to sweep the dining room before dinner / The dining room needs to be swept before dinner. - Trebalo bi pomesti blagovaonicu prije večere.
= The dining room should be swept before dinner / It would be good to sweep it before dinner.
So trebalo bi sounds a bit softer, more like advice or a recommendation.
Can the word order change?
Yes. Croatian word order is quite flexible.
The neutral order here is:
- Trebalo bi pomesti blagovaonicu prije večere.
But you could also hear:
- Blagovaonicu bi trebalo pomesti prije večere.
- Prije večere trebalo bi pomesti blagovaonicu.
These versions shift the emphasis a little:
- putting blagovaonicu first highlights the dining room
- putting prije večere first highlights the time
The original sentence is a very natural default order.
Is blagovaonica the only word for dining room?
No. Blagovaonica is a standard word for dining room, but depending on region and variety, learners may also come across other words.
Still, in this sentence, blagovaonica is perfectly normal and clear.
Is this a very formal sentence?
No, it is neutral and natural.
It is not slang, but it is also not overly formal. You could use it in everyday speech or writing when making a practical suggestion or stating what ought to be done.
Why is the sentence not saying who should do the sweeping?
Because Croatian often leaves the agent unspecified when it is unimportant, obvious, or general.
So the sentence focuses on what should be done, not who should do it:
- Trebalo bi pomesti blagovaonicu prije večere.
= The dining room should be swept before dinner.
If you wanted to specify the person, you would use a different structure, for example:
- Trebali bismo pomesti blagovaonicu prije večere.
= We should sweep the dining room before dinner.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CroatianMaster Croatian — from Trebalo bi pomesti blagovaonicu prije večere to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions