Breakdown of Avui no porto efectiu, per això trauré diners del caixer.
Questions & Answers about Avui no porto efectiu, per això trauré diners del caixer.
Why is porto used here instead of tinc?
Because portar often means to carry / to have on you, not just to bring.
So No porto efectiu means I’m not carrying any cash / I don’t have cash on me.
If you said no tinc efectiu, that can also be understood, but no porto efectiu is especially natural when talking about what you physically have with you at that moment.
Why isn’t the subject jo included?
Catalan often leaves out subject pronouns when they are clear from the verb ending.
- porto = I carry / I have on me
- trauré = I will take out / withdraw
So jo is unnecessary unless you want emphasis or contrast.
For example:
- Avui no porto efectiu... = neutral
- Jo avui no porto efectiu... = more emphatic, like I’m the one who doesn’t have cash today
What exactly does efectiu mean?
Efectiu means cash.
It can function like a noun in this context, just as in English you can say cash without adding money.
So:
- portar efectiu = to carry cash
- pagar en efectiu = to pay in cash
It does not mean effective here, even though it looks similar to the English word.
Why is there no article before efectiu?
Catalan often omits the article with uncountable or general nouns, especially when talking about something in a broad sense.
So no porto efectiu is natural in the same way English says I’m not carrying cash, not necessarily the cash.
Adding an article would usually change the meaning:
- no porto efectiu = I’m not carrying cash
- no porto l’efectiu = I’m not carrying the cash, meaning some specific cash already mentioned
What does per això mean exactly?
Per això means that’s why, for that reason, or therefore.
It links the first idea to the result:
- Avui no porto efectiu → reason
- per això trauré diners del caixer → consequence
It is a very common expression in Catalan.
Do not confuse it with:
- per exemple = for example
- però = but
- això = this / that
Here, per això works as a connector meaning because of that.
How does trauré work? What verb is it from?
Trauré is the future tense of the verb treure, which means to take out, to remove, and in banking contexts, to withdraw.
So:
- treure = to take out / withdraw
- trauré = I will take out / I will withdraw
This is an irregular future form, because it does not keep the full infinitive treure in the stem.
Some useful forms:
- trec = I take out
- treia = I was taking out
- vaig treure = I took out
- trauré = I will take out
In this sentence, trauré diners means I’ll withdraw money.
Why does Catalan say diners in the plural?
Because diners is normally used as a plural noun meaning money.
This is one of those nouns that does not match English exactly.
So Catalan says:
- No tinc diners = I don’t have money
- Necessito diners = I need money
Even though it looks plural, you usually translate it simply as money, not moneys.
Why is it del caixer and not de el caixer?
Because de + el contracts to del in Catalan.
So:
- de + el caixer → del caixer
This is very common:
- del = de + el
- al = a + el
So diners del caixer means money from the ATM.
Does caixer really mean ATM?
Yes, in everyday Catalan, caixer often refers to an ATM, especially when the context is about taking out money.
More fully, you may also hear:
- caixer automàtic = ATM / cash machine
In casual speech, people often shorten it to just caixer when the meaning is obvious.
Be aware that caixer / caixera can also mean cashier, depending on context. Here, because the sentence says trauré diners, it clearly means ATM.
Why is the future used in trauré instead of something like a present tense?
The future is used because the speaker is talking about what they are going to do next.
- Avui no porto efectiu = present situation
- trauré diners del caixer = future action
Catalan, like English, can use a future form for a planned next step.
In conversation, Catalan can also use other ways to express the future, such as:
- treuré diners = I’ll withdraw money
- vaig a treure diners = I’m going to withdraw money
Both are possible, but trauré is perfectly natural here.
Is the word order important in Avui no porto efectiu?
The word order is natural, but somewhat flexible.
Avui at the beginning sets the time frame: today.
So the sentence starts by establishing the situation for today, then gives the result.
You could also hear:
- No porto efectiu avui
- Avui no en porto, d’efectiu in more conversational styles
But Avui no porto efectiu is a straightforward, standard way to say it.
What is the role of the comma in this sentence?
The comma separates the reason from the consequence:
- Avui no porto efectiu = reason
- per això trauré diners del caixer = consequence
It helps readability and reflects the pause you would naturally make when speaking.
It is not absolutely the core of the grammar, but it is good punctuation in a sentence like this.
Could Catalan use en anywhere in this sentence?
Yes, in some contexts Catalan could replace efectiu or diners with the pronoun en, depending on what has already been mentioned.
For example:
- Avui no en porto = Today I’m not carrying any
- N’hauré de treure del caixer = I’ll have to withdraw some from the ATM
That said, for learners, the full version Avui no porto efectiu, per això trauré diners del caixer is clearer and easier to understand.
Is this sentence standard Catalan, and would people really say it?
Yes. It is standard and natural.
A native speaker might also say similar versions such as:
- Avui no porto diners en efectiu, per això trauré diners del caixer.
- No porto cash, així que trauré diners del caixer. in more informal speech with an English borrowing
- Avui no tinc efectiu, així que aniré al caixer.
But the original sentence is completely normal and idiomatic.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CatalanMaster Catalan — from Avui no porto efectiu, per això trauré diners del caixer to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions