Breakdown of Quan hi ha molt vent, el pare tanca la finestra.
Questions & Answers about Quan hi ha molt vent, el pare tanca la finestra.
What does quan mean here: when or whenever?
In this sentence, quan can be understood as when, but in practice it often has the sense of whenever.
Because both clauses are in the present tense, the sentence sounds like a habitual or repeated action:
- Quan hi ha molt vent, el pare tanca la finestra.
- Whenever there is a lot of wind, father closes the window.
So when is correct, but whenever helps show the idea more clearly in English.
Why do we say hi ha? What does hi do?
Hi ha is the standard Catalan expression for there is or there are.
It comes from the verb haver-hi, which is used to talk about existence:
- Hi ha vent = there is wind
- Hi ha gent = there are people
In this expression, hi is part of the structure. You usually do not translate it word for word on its own here. It is simply necessary in Catalan.
So:
- ha alone does not mean there is
- hi ha does
Could I also say fa molt vent instead of hi ha molt vent?
Yes. Fa molt vent is also very natural Catalan.
There is a small difference in feel:
- fa molt vent = it is very windy
- hi ha molt vent = there is a lot of wind
In many everyday situations, they are very close in meaning. A learner should understand both.
Why is it molt vent and not molta vent?
Because vent is a masculine singular noun in Catalan.
So the quantifier must agree with it:
- molt vent = a lot of wind
- molta pluja = a lot of rain
- molts núvols = many clouds
- moltes fulles = many leaves
Also, vent here is being used as an uncountable idea, like wind in English, so the singular makes sense.
Why does Catalan say el pare instead of just pare?
Catalan very often uses the definite article with family members when talking about them:
- el pare = father / the father
- la mare = mother
- l’avi = grandfather
This is normal in Catalan, even though English usually does not use the in the same way.
However, when you speak to the person directly, the article is usually dropped:
- Pare, tanca la finestra. = Dad, close the window.
What form is tanca?
Tanca is the third-person singular present indicative of the verb tancar, meaning to close.
So:
- jo tanco = I close
- tu tanques = you close
- ell/ella tanca = he/she closes
In the sentence, the subject is el pare, so tanca means the father closes.
Why is the present tense used here?
The present tense is used because the sentence describes a habitual or general situation.
It does not necessarily mean that it is happening right now. Instead, it means this is what usually happens:
- when there is a lot of wind,
- the father closes the window.
This is very similar to English present simple in sentences like:
- When it rains, we stay inside.
- When it is windy, he closes the window.
Why is it la finestra and not una finestra?
La finestra uses the definite article because it refers to a specific, understood window.
That is usually the natural choice here: the speaker and listener know which window is meant.
- la finestra = the window
- una finestra = a window
If you said una finestra, it would sound less specific, as if it were just any window.
Can I put quan hi ha molt vent at the end?
Yes. You can also say:
El pare tanca la finestra quan hi ha molt vent.
That is completely natural and means the same thing.
The difference is mainly one of emphasis:
Quan hi ha molt vent, el pare tanca la finestra.
The windy condition is introduced first.El pare tanca la finestra quan hi ha molt vent.
The main action comes first.
Both are correct.
Why is there a comma in the sentence?
The comma is used because the sentence begins with a subordinate time clause:
- Quan hi ha molt vent, ...
When this kind of clause comes first in Catalan, a comma is normally used before the main clause.
If the time clause comes at the end, the comma is usually not needed:
- El pare tanca la finestra quan hi ha molt vent.
More from this lesson
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CatalanMaster Catalan — from Quan hi ha molt vent, el pare tanca la finestra to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions