Breakdown of لم تعد القطة تخدش الباب.
Questions & Answers about لم تعد القطة تخدش الباب.
What does لم تعد mean here?
In this sentence, لم تعد + imperfect verb means no longer or not anymore.
So لم تعد القطة تخدش الباب means that the cat used to scratch the door, but now it does not.
Why is it تعد instead of تعود?
The basic imperfect form of عاد is تعود.
After لم, the verb must go into the jussive form. With a hollow verb like عاد, that changes تعود to تعدْ.
So:
- تعود = she returns / she goes back / she resumes
- لم تعد = she did not return / she no longer...
Before القطة, it is commonly pronounced تعدِ القطة because a helping vowel is inserted in speech.
What exactly does لم do?
لم is a negation particle that:
- negates an imperfect verb
- puts that verb into the jussive
Very often, لم + imperfect gives a past meaning like did not.
But with عاد + imperfect, the whole expression often has the idiomatic meaning no longer.
Why are there two verbs here: تعد and تخدش?
Because عاد is being used in a helper-like role here.
- تعد gives the idea of no longer
- تخدش gives the main action: scratch
So the structure is essentially:
لم تعد + verb = no longer + does that verb
Why do both verbs start with تـ? Doesn’t that usually mean you?
In the imperfect, تـ can mark:
- you
- or she / it for a feminine singular subject
Here the subject is القطة, which is feminine singular, so both verbs are third-person feminine singular:
- تعد = she/it no longer...
- تخدش = she/it scratches
So here تـ does not mean you.
Why is القطة feminine?
قطة is a feminine noun and specifically refers to a female cat.
That is why the verbs are feminine:
- تعد
- تخدش
If you used القط instead, you would normally use masculine verb forms:
لم يعد القط يخدش الباب
Could لم تعد ever mean did not return instead of no longer?
Yes.
By itself, عاد means returned or came back. So in another sentence:
لم تعد القطة إلى البيت
= The cat did not return home
But when لم تعد is followed directly by another imperfect verb, as in:
لم تعد القطة تخدش الباب
it is usually understood as no longer.
Why is القطة after the verb?
Because verb-first word order is very common in Arabic.
So لم تعد القطة تخدش الباب is a very normal Arabic sentence pattern.
You can also say:
القطة لم تعد تخدش الباب
That version is also correct, but it gives a bit more topic emphasis to the cat.
What is the job of الباب in the sentence?
الباب is the direct object of تخدش.
The cat is doing the scratching, and the door is what is being scratched.
In fully vocalized Arabic, it would be accusative:
البابَ
What case are القطة and الباب in?
In a fully vocalized version:
- القطةُ is nominative because it is the subject
- البابَ is accusative because it is the direct object
So the fully marked sentence is:
لَمْ تَعُدِ الْقِطَّةُ تَخْدِشُ الْبَابَ
In normal everyday writing, those case endings are usually not written.
Does تخدش mean one scratch right now, or a repeated action?
The Arabic imperfect can express:
- a present action
- a repeated action
- a habitual action
- a general statement
In this sentence, the most natural meaning is habitual or general:
the cat no longer scratches the door
or
the cat doesn’t scratch the door anymore
How would I pronounce the whole sentence?
A formal fully vocalized reading is:
لَمْ تَعُدِ الْقِطَّةُ تَخْدِشُ الْبَابَ
A rough pronunciation is:
lam taʿudi l-qiṭṭatu takhdishu l-bāba
In normal speech, many speakers reduce or drop full case endings, but this gives you the grammatical pronunciation.
Could I use لا instead of لم here?
Not if you want the standard MSA meaning no longer.
For this idea, Arabic commonly uses:
لم يعد + imperfect
So لم تعد القطة تخدش الباب is the natural MSA way to say the cat no longer scratches the door.
Using لا here would usually be understood differently, not as this standard not anymore expression.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning ArabicMaster Arabic — from لم تعد القطة تخدش الباب to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions