Breakdown of Здесь нельзя курить, потому что нельзя нарушать закон.
здесь
here
потому что
because
нельзя
one must not
курить
to smoke
нарушать
to break (rules, laws)
закон
the law
Questions & Answers about Здесь нельзя курить, потому что нельзя нарушать закон.
Why are курить and нарушать both in the imperfective aspect here?
When нельзя is followed by an imperfective verb, it means the action is prohibited or forbidden. Because we are talking about rules here, we need the imperfective to express that you are not allowed to smoke or break the law.
What would it mean if we used the perfective verbs покурить and нарушить?
If you use нельзя with a perfective verb, it changes the meaning from 'forbidden' to 'physically impossible to achieve'. For example, нельзя покурить would mean you literally cannot manage to smoke right now (perhaps you lost your lighter, or the wind is too strong).
Does the negative word нельзя force закон into the genitive case?
No, the 'genitive of negation' is optional and much less common with impersonal words like нельзя. The verb нарушать takes a standard direct object in the accusative case. Since закон is an inanimate masculine noun, its accusative form is identical to its dictionary form.
Can I use нарушать to say I broke my phone or a window?
No, нарушать is used specifically for violating or disrupting abstract things. You use it to break a law (закон), a rule (правило), a promise (обещание), or the silence (тишина). To physically break an object, you would use a different verb like ломать.
Learn Здесь нельзя курить, потому что нельзя нарушать закон and more in Russian
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free