Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching Russian grammar and vocabulary.
Questions & Answers about А кто там?
Where is the word for 'is' in this sentence?
In Russian, the present tense of the verb 'to be' (am, is, are) is almost always skipped. So кто там literally means 'who there', which naturally translates to 'who is there'.
Why does this sentence start with А instead of И for 'and'?
И is used to simply link things together, like 'you and me'. А is used to shift the topic or show a slight contrast. Starting a question with А makes it a natural follow-up, like asking 'And what about over there—who is there?'
Does кто act like a subject pronoun here?
Yes! Кто (who) is a question word that takes the place of the subject. If you were answering this question, you would replace it with a subject pronoun from this lesson, like он (he) or она (she). For example, you could answer: Он там (He is there).
Can I add a pronoun to make it А кто он там (And who is he there)?
No, that would sound unnatural. Since кто (who) already acts as the subject, adding он (he) would be redundant, exactly like saying 'And who he is there?' in English.