Purpose vs. cause (po co / dlaczego)

Purpose vs. Cause

In English, we often use "why" for almost everything. In Polish, there is a clear distinction between asking about the purpose of an action (what for) and the cause of a situation (why / for what reason).

Po co: What For?

When you want to know the intention, goal, or purpose behind someone's actions, use po co. It literally means "for what" and looks to the future: To what end are you doing this?

what for
po co
What did you buy this old bunker for all by yourself?
Po co sam kupiłeś ten stary bunkier?
What are you hoarding these things for?
Po co gromadzisz te rzeczy?

Dlaczego and Czemu: Why?

When you want to know the cause or reason behind a situation, use dlaczego. It asks about the facts or events that led to the current state of things. You will also frequently hear czemu, which means exactly the same thing but is slightly more conversational.

Why was this bunker so cheap?
Dlaczego ten bunkier był taki tani?
Why is he hoarding supplies by himself?
Czemu on sam gromadzi zapasy?

Spotting the Difference

Notice how the choice of question word changes the focus. Use po co when questioning someone's motives, and dlaczego when investigating facts, states, or underlying causes.

What did you bring these cans of food for?
Po co przyniosłeś te konserwy?
Why are you eating cold canned food instead of dinner?
Dlaczego jesz zimną konserwę zamiast obiadu?

You might build a shelter with a specific goal in mind (po co), but the door is locked due to a factual reason (dlaczego).

What did he build this shelter for all by himself before the disaster?
Po co on sam zbudował ten schron przed katastrofą?
Why is this hidden shelter closed?
Dlaczego ten ukryty schron jest zamknięty?

Putting It Together

In a tense situation, like surviving an imaginary crisis, you might understand the cause of someone's feelings, but still question the logic of their actions.

I understand why you are afraid, but what did you leave the city for?
Rozumiem, dlaczego się boisz, ale po co wyjechałeś z miasta?

Contributors