Breakdown of Mana tahu mereka boleh memutar roda tembikar.
Questions & Answers about Mana tahu mereka boleh memutar roda tembikar.
Yes, if you break it down word-for-word, mana often means where / which, and tahu means know. But in this expression, mana tahu is an idiomatic phrase.
Here it means something like:
- who knows
- maybe
- you never know
So in this sentence, Mana tahu mereka boleh memutar roda tembikar means something like Who knows, they might be able to turn/spin a pottery wheel.
This is a good example of how Malay often uses short expressions that do not translate literally into natural English.
That is a very natural question. In many contexts, mana does mean where or which, for example:
- Di mana? = Where?
- Yang mana? = Which one?
But in fixed expressions, the meaning can shift. In mana tahu, it no longer functions as a normal question word. Instead, the whole phrase acts as an idiom meaning who knows / maybe.
So the key point is:
- mana on its own: often where / which
- mana tahu as a set phrase: who knows / maybe
You should learn mana tahu as one chunk rather than trying to interpret each word separately every time.