Breakdown of Sive legatum sive fideicommissum scribitur, signator tabulas obsignat.
Questions & Answers about Sive legatum sive fideicommissum scribitur, signator tabulas obsignat.
What does sive ... sive mean here?
Sive ... sive is a correlative conjunction. It means whether ... or or either ... or.
So:
- sive legatum sive fideicommissum scribitur = whether a legacy or a fideicommissum is written
It presents two alternatives, but the main clause applies in either case.
Why are legatum and fideicommissum in the same case?
They are both in the nominative singular, because each one can serve as the subject of scribitur.
In other words, Latin is really saying:
- sive legatum scribitur
- sive fideicommissum scribitur
Both nouns are alternatives to each other, so they appear in the same form.
Also, both are neuter second-declension nouns, and for neuter nouns the nominative singular and accusative singular look the same, ending in -um.
Why is scribitur singular instead of plural?
Because sive ... sive presents the nouns as alternatives, not as a combined plural subject.
The sense is:
- whether a legacy is written
- or a fideicommissum is written
Each option is singular, so the verb is singular: scribitur = is written.
If Latin meant that both things together were being written as a plural subject, a plural verb would make more sense, but that is not what this sentence is doing.
What form is scribitur?
Scribitur is:
- 3rd person singular
- present tense
- passive voice
- indicative mood
from the verb scribere = to write
So literally it means is written.
Why is the verb passive in scribitur?
The sentence focuses on the thing being written, not on the person writing it.
So Latin says:
- legatum scribitur = a legacy is written
- not someone writes a legacy
This is very natural Latin. The agent is either unknown, unimportant, or simply not mentioned.
Does the present tense scribitur mean present time only?
Not necessarily. In a sentence like this, the present tense often expresses a general rule, habit, or customary procedure.
So the idea is closer to:
- whenever a legacy or fideicommissum is written, the signator seals the tablets
rather than only right now, at this moment.
What is the grammatical role of signator?
Signator is the nominative singular subject of obsignat.
So:
- signator = the person doing the action
- obsignat = seals
In other words, the signator seals.
The noun itself means something like signer, sealer, or witness who seals/signs, depending on context.
What case is tabulas, and why is it plural?
Tabulas is accusative plural, the direct object of obsignat.
So:
- signator tabulas obsignat = the signator seals the tablets
Why plural? In Roman contexts, legal documents were often written on tablets (for example, multiple wax tablets tied together). So the plural is perfectly natural.
Also, tabulae can refer not just to physical tablets, but to the document itself as embodied in those tablets.
What does obsignat mean exactly?
Obsignat is the 3rd person singular present active indicative of obsignare.
It means:
- seals
- seals up
- affixes a seal to
The prefix ob- adds the idea of sealing over or securing something formally. So obsignare is stronger and more specific than simply marking or writing.
Why is the word order different from English?
Latin word order is much more flexible than English word order because the endings show the grammatical roles.
English depends heavily on position:
- the signator seals the tablets
Latin can move the words around more freely:
- signator tabulas obsignat
- tabulas signator obsignat
- obsignat signator tabulas
All of these could work, though they may differ in emphasis.
Here, the sentence begins with the whether ... or clause, setting up the condition first, and then gives the main action.
Are legatum and fideicommissum regular nouns grammatically?
Yes. Grammatically, both are second-declension neuter nouns.
That means they follow the normal neuter pattern:
- singular nominative/accusative: -um
- plural nominative/accusative: -a
So forms like these are what you would expect from regular neuter nouns of that declension.
Is there any special nuance in translating tabulas literally as tablets?
Yes. A learner may see tablets and think only of physical objects, but in Roman legal language tabulae often means the written legal document as preserved on those tablets.
So depending on context, English might say:
- tablets
- document
- will
- written instrument
The Latin still literally says tabulas, but the practical sense can be broader than just the wooden or wax tablets themselves.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Sive legatum sive fideicommissum scribitur, signator tabulas obsignat to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions