Breakdown of kantanna tetuduki ni site ha, hituyouna syorui ga ooi.
Questions & Answers about kantanna tetuduki ni site ha, hituyouna syorui ga ooi.
What does にしては mean in this sentence?
にしては means something like:
- for...
- considering...
- for something that is supposed to be...
It shows that the speaker thinks the result is surprising or does not match what would normally be expected.
So in 簡単な手続きにしては、必要な書類が多い, the idea is:
- If it is a simple procedure, you would expect fewer required documents.
- But actually there are a lot.
- So the second part feels unexpected.
A natural English gloss is:
- For a simple procedure, there are a lot of required documents.
Is にしては related to the verb する?
Yes. Historically and grammatically, にしては comes from にする / にして plus は.
In modern Japanese, though, learners usually treat 〜にしては as a set expression meaning:
- for
- considering
- in spite of being
So while it is connected to する, in this kind of sentence it is best learned as one grammar pattern: X にしては Y.
Pattern:
- Noun + にしては
- Plain form + にしては in some cases as well
Here, 簡単な手続き is treated as the thing being evaluated, and にしては means for a simple procedure.
Why is it 簡単な手続き and not just 簡単手続き?
Because 簡単 is a na-adjective.
When a na-adjective directly modifies a noun, it usually takes な:
- 簡単な手続き = a simple procedure
- 静かな部屋 = a quiet room
- 便利なアプリ = a convenient app
So:
- 簡単 by itself can mean simple
- but before 手続き, you need 簡単な
That is why the first part is 簡単な手続き.
What exactly does 手続き mean here?
手続き means procedure, process, or formal steps.
Depending on context, it can refer to things like:
- an application procedure
- administrative paperwork
- official processing steps
- some formal process you need to complete
In this sentence, it probably means something like an official or practical procedure, especially because 必要な書類 follows it. That combination strongly suggests paperwork or administration.
Why is it 必要な書類が多い and not 必要な書類は多い?
Here, が marks 必要な書類 as the thing that is being described by 多い.
Structure:
- 必要な書類 = required documents
- が = subject marker
- 多い = are many / are numerous
So the sentence is saying:
- The required documents are many.
Using が is very natural when identifying what is many, few, expensive, difficult, etc.
If you used は, it would create a stronger contrast, something like:
- As for the required documents, they are many which is possible in some contexts, but less neutral here.
So が is the normal choice.
Why is it 多い instead of 多くの?
Because 多い is being used as the main predicate of the sentence.
Compare:
必要な書類が多い
- The required documents are many
- Here 多い finishes the sentence.
多くの必要な書類
- many required documents
- Here 多くの modifies a noun that comes after it.
In this sentence, nothing comes after 多い, so it is acting as the predicate:
- 必要な書類が多い = There are many required documents.
That is why 多い is correct here.
Does にしては mean the same thing as のに here?
They are similar, but not exactly the same.
- 〜にしては = for... / considering...; compares reality to what would normally be expected
- 〜のに = although / even though; more directly expresses contradiction
So:
- 簡単な手続きにしては、必要な書類が多い = For a simple procedure, there are a lot of required documents. = emphasizes judgment based on expectation
Compare:
- 簡単な手続きなのに、必要な書類が多い = Even though it’s a simple procedure, there are a lot of required documents. = stronger direct contradiction
Both can work, but にしては is especially good when you mean:
- given that it is called/simple as a category, this is more than expected
What kind of nuance does the whole sentence have?
The nuance is mildly evaluative or slightly critical.
The speaker is basically saying:
- This procedure is supposed to be simple.
- For something simple, I would expect less paperwork.
- But in reality, the number of required documents is surprisingly high.
So it often carries a feeling like:
- That’s more than I expected
- That seems excessive
- It’s not as simple as it sounds
It is not just a neutral fact; it includes the speaker’s sense of mismatch between expectation and reality.
Why is there a comma after にしては?
The comma shows a pause after the comparison phrase:
- 簡単な手続きにしては、
- 必要な書類が多い。
This is very common in Japanese writing when the first part sets up the condition, frame, or contrast.
The comma is not absolutely required in every case, but it is natural and helps readability. It separates:
- the standard of comparison: for a simple procedure
- the main comment: there are many required documents
Is there an omitted topic like この手続きは?
Yes, Japanese often leaves out things that are understood from context.
A fuller version in context might be something like:
- この手続きは、簡単な手続きにしては、必要な書類が多い。
But Japanese does not need to state this procedure if the topic is already obvious.
So the sentence can naturally stand on its own, with the meaning understood as something like:
- For a simple procedure, it has a lot of required documents.
Omitting the obvious topic is very normal in Japanese.
Can 簡単な手続きにしては be understood as for something that counts as a simple procedure?
Yes, that is a very good way to understand it.
にしては often has the nuance of:
- for something of that type
- considering that it is classified as X
- for something said to be X
So 簡単な手続きにしては is not just describing the procedure as simple. It also implies:
- if we call this a simple procedure,
- or if we judge it by the standards of a simple procedure,
then the number of required documents is surprisingly large.
That is why にしては feels more nuanced than a simple because it is simple type of expression.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from kantanna tetuduki ni site ha, hituyouna syorui ga ooi to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions