Breakdown of Meg tudja mondani, melyik peronról indul ez a járat?
Questions & Answers about Meg tudja mondani, melyik peronról indul ez a járat?
Why does the sentence start with Meg tudja mondani? Does it literally mean can you tell?
Yes. Meg tudja mondani means can you tell (me) in a polite/formal way.
- tudja = you can / you know how to (formal you, or he/she depending on context)
- mondani = to say / to tell
- meg is a verbal prefix that often makes the action feel complete or successfully carried out
So Meg tudja mondani...? is a very common polite way to ask for information, similar to:
- Could you tell me...?
- Can you tell me...?
Without meg, the sentence would sound less natural here.
Why is it tudja and not tudsz?
Because tudja is the formal form of you here.
Hungarian has informal and formal ways to say you:
- tudsz = you can (informal, singular)
- tudja = you can (formal, singular; literally the same form as he/she can)
So this sentence is polite, appropriate for asking a stranger, station staff, or an older person:
- Meg tudja mondani...? = formal/polite
- Meg tudod mondani...? = informal
What exactly does meg do in Meg tudja mondani?
Meg is a verbal prefix. In this sentence it suggests completion: not just say, but tell successfully / give the answer.
Compare the feeling:
- mondani = to say
- megmondani = to tell, to give the answer, to say it clearly/completely
That is why Hungarian often uses megmondani in questions like:
- Meg tudja mondani az időt? = Can you tell me the time?
- Meg tudod mondani, hol van...? = Can you tell me where ... is?
So meg does not translate as a separate English word here, but it is an important part of the natural Hungarian expression.
Why is meg separated from mondani? I thought the verb was megmondani.
Good question. The full verb is indeed megmondani. But in Hungarian, verbal prefixes often separate from the verb when another element comes before the verb, especially with modal-like verbs such as tud.
So:
- dictionary form: megmondani
- in the sentence: Meg tudja mondani
This is normal Hungarian word order. The prefix meg moves in front of tudja, while mondani stays at the end of that verb phrase.
A very similar pattern:
- El tudok menni. = I can go.
- Be tudsz jönni? = Can you come in?
What is melyik and how is it different from mi or milyen?
Melyik means which one.
Here it introduces the indirect question:
- melyik peronról = from which platform
Compare:
- mi? = what?
- melyik? = which one?
- milyen? = what kind of? / what is it like?
Examples:
- Mi ez? = What is this?
- Melyik vonat megy Budapestre? = Which train goes to Budapest?
- Milyen vonat ez? = What kind of train is this?
Since the speaker is choosing among possible platforms, melyik is the right word.
Why is it peronról and not just peron?
Because Hungarian uses case endings where English often uses prepositions.
peronról breaks down as:
- peron = platform
- -ról / -ről = from off / from
So:
- melyik peronról indul = departs from which platform
Hungarian expresses from the platform with the ending -ról, rather than a separate word like from.
Why is the ending -ról and not -ről?
Because of vowel harmony.
Hungarian suffixes often change depending on the vowels in the word:
- back-vowel words usually take -ról
- front-vowel words usually take -ről
peron has back vowels, so:
- peronról
Compare:
- asztalról = from the table
- székről = from the chair
This is a general Hungarian pattern you will see with many suffixes.
What does indul mean exactly?
indul means depart, leave, or set off.
In transport contexts, it is very common for buses, trains, trams, and flights:
- A vonat hatkor indul. = The train leaves at six.
- Mikor indul a busz? = When does the bus leave?
So in your sentence:
- melyik peronról indul ez a járat = which platform this service departs from
What does járat mean here? Is it the same as train?
Not exactly. Járat is more general. It means something like service, route, or scheduled departure.
Depending on context, it can refer to:
- a train service
- a bus service
- a flight
- another regular transport connection
So ez a járat means this service or this departure. In English, we might translate it more specifically depending on context, but Hungarian keeps it broader.
Why is it ez a járat and not just ez járat?
Because Hungarian normally uses the definite article with a noun after ez and az.
So the natural pattern is:
- ez a könyv = this book
- ez a vonat = this train
- ez a járat = this service
Literally, it looks like this the service, but that is just how Hungarian grammar works.
Why does the sentence use a comma after mondani?
Because the rest of the sentence is an embedded question:
- Meg tudja mondani, ... ? = Can you tell me, ... ?
The part after the comma:
- melyik peronról indul ez a járat
is an indirect question, equivalent to which platform this service leaves from.
Hungarian commonly separates this kind of clause with a comma.
Could I also say Honnan indul ez a járat?
Yes, but it means something slightly different.
- Honnan indul ez a járat? = Where does this service depart from?
- Melyik peronról indul ez a járat? = Which platform does this service depart from?
So honnan asks more generally from where, while melyik peronról specifically asks from which platform.
Is there an omitted nekem meaning to me in this sentence?
Yes, you can think of it that way. Hungarian often leaves out things that are clear from context.
- Meg tudja mondani...? naturally means Can you tell me...?
If you wanted, you could make the to me explicit:
- Meg tudja nekem mondani...?
But in everyday speech, nekem is usually unnecessary here. The shorter version is very common and completely natural.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning HungarianMaster Hungarian — from Meg tudja mondani, melyik peronról indul ez a járat to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions