בפיקוח ההנדסי התגלה ליקוי בנייה.

Questions & Answers about בפיקוח ההנדסי התגלה ליקוי בנייה.

What does בפיקוח ההנדסי mean, and what is the role of ב־ here?

ב־ is the preposition in, during, under, or sometimes as part of, depending on context.

So בפיקוח ההנדסי can mean something like:

  • in the engineering inspection
  • during the engineering supervision
  • under the engineering oversight

The exact English wording depends on the situation, but the basic idea is that something was discovered in the course of or through engineering inspection/supervision.


Why doesn’t פיקוח have ה־ in front of it, even though ההנדסי is definite?

It actually is definite here.

The full form is:

  • ב + הפיקוח ההנדסי

But in Hebrew, when certain prepositions attach to a noun with ה־ (the), the forms contract:

  • ב + ה... becomes בַ / בַּ...
  • in unpointed modern spelling, this is often just written ב...

So בפיקוח ההנדסי is really functioning as in the engineering inspection/supervision.

Also, adjectives in Hebrew usually match the noun in definiteness, so:

  • פיקוח הנדסי = engineering supervision / an engineering inspection
  • הפיקוח ההנדסי = the engineering supervision / inspection
  • בפיקוח ההנדסי = in the engineering supervision / inspection

What does התגלה mean here?

התגלה means was discovered, was revealed, or came to light.

It comes from the root ג־ל־ה, which is connected with revealing or uncovering.
In this sentence, the form is a past-tense, masculine singular form in the Nif'al pattern, which often has a passive or middle meaning.

So:

  • גילה = he discovered / revealed
  • התגלה = it was discovered / it came to light

In this sentence, התגלה matches ליקוי because ליקוי is masculine singular.


Why is התגלה singular masculine?

Because the subject is ליקוי בנייה.

The head noun is ליקוי, and ליקוי is:

  • masculine
  • singular

So the verb agrees with it:

  • התגלה ליקוי בנייה = a construction defect was discovered

If the subject were feminine singular, you would expect a feminine verb form.
If it were plural, the verb would normally be plural too.


What exactly does ליקוי בנייה mean?

ליקוי בנייה means construction defect, building defect, or defect in construction.

It is a noun + noun structure, often called a construct relationship in Hebrew, even though modern Hebrew often uses such combinations quite flexibly.

Here:

  • ליקוי = defect / flaw
  • בנייה = construction / building

Together, they mean a defect related to construction.

A natural English translation is usually:

  • a construction defect
  • a building defect

Why is it ליקוי בנייה and not ליקוי של בנייה?

Hebrew often prefers a compact noun + noun structure where English might use of.

So instead of:

  • a defect of construction

Hebrew commonly says:

  • ליקוי בנייה

This is very natural and common in formal or technical language.

Using של is possible in some contexts in Hebrew, but here it would sound less natural and less concise.
For this kind of fixed or professional expression, ליקוי בנייה is the normal choice.


Why does the verb come before the subject in התגלה ליקוי בנייה?

Because Hebrew often allows, and frequently prefers, verb-first word order, especially in formal writing or reporting style.

So:

  • התגלה ליקוי בנייה = literally was discovered a construction defect
  • natural English: a construction defect was discovered

This verb-before-subject order is very normal in Hebrew.

You could also reorder it for emphasis, for example:

  • ליקוי בנייה התגלה בפיקוח ההנדסי

That is still grammatical, but it shifts the focus slightly.


Is בפיקוח better translated as in the inspection, during the inspection, or under supervision?

All of those can be possible depending on context.

פיקוח can mean:

  • supervision
  • oversight
  • inspection
  • monitoring

So בפיקוח ההנדסי may suggest:

  • something discovered during an engineering inspection
  • something found through engineering oversight
  • something noticed under engineering supervision

If the sentence comes from construction, safety, or legal reporting, during the engineering inspection or in the engineering supervision process may fit best.


Why isn’t there an את in this sentence?

Because ליקוי בנייה is not a direct object here.

In this sentence, ליקוי בנייה is the subject of התגלה:

  • A construction defect was discovered

Hebrew uses את only before a definite direct object.

Compare:

  • המפקח גילה ליקוי בנייה = The inspector discovered a construction defect
    No את, because the object is indefinite.

  • המפקח גילה את ליקוי הבנייה = The inspector discovered the construction defect
    Here את appears because the object is definite.

But in your sentence, the structure is passive-like/intransitive:

  • התגלה ליקוי בנייה = A construction defect was discovered

So there is no direct object marker.


Could this sentence be translated as active instead of passive?

Yes, in English you could sometimes translate it more actively depending on style, even though the Hebrew uses התגלה.

Possible translations include:

  • A construction defect was discovered during the engineering inspection.
  • The engineering inspection revealed a construction defect.

The second version is more active in English, but it slightly reshapes the sentence.
The Hebrew original keeps the focus on the defect being discovered, not on who discovered it.

So the most direct translation is usually the passive-style one:

  • A construction defect was discovered during the engineering inspection.
AI Language TutorTry it ↗
Your avatar
“What's the best way to learn Hebrew grammar?”
Hebrew grammar becomes intuitive with practice. Focus on understanding the core patterns first — how sentences are structured, how verbs change form, and how words relate to each other. Our course breaks these concepts into small lessons so you can build understanding step by step.

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Hebrew

Master Hebrew — from בפיקוח ההנדסי התגלה ליקוי בנייה to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions