Breakdown of כמו שכתוב בחשבון החשמל, התעריף שונה.
Questions & Answers about כמו שכתוב בחשבון החשמל, התעריף שונה.
Why is there no Hebrew word for is in התעריף שונה?
In the present tense, Hebrew usually does not use a separate word for to be.
So:
- התעריף שונה = The tariff/rate is different
- literally, it is just the tariff different
This is completely normal in Hebrew.
If you wanted past or future, then Hebrew would use forms of היה / יהיה:
- התעריף היה שונה = The tariff was different
- התעריף יהיה שונה = The tariff will be different
What does כמו שכתוב mean exactly?
כמו שכתוב means as written or as it is written.
It breaks down like this:
- כמו = like / as
- ש־ = that / which / as
- כתוב = written
So the whole phrase means something like:
- as written
- as is written
- just as it says
This is a very common Hebrew expression when referring to something written in a text, bill, sign, contract, message, and so on.
Why is there a ש־ in כמו שכתוב? Why not just כמו כתוב?
The ש־ connects כמו to a whole clause.
- כמו שכתוב = as it is written
- not just like written
In English, we often need a full structure such as as it says or as is written. Hebrew uses ש־ very often to introduce that kind of subordinate clause.
So כמו שכתוב sounds natural, while כמו כתוב would sound incomplete or incorrect in normal usage.
What kind of form is כתוב here?
כתוב is the passive participle of the verb לכתוב (to write).
So:
- כותב = writing / writes
- כתוב = written
In כמו שכתוב, it means written:
- כמו שכתוב בחשבון החשמל = as written on the electricity bill
This passive participle is very common in Hebrew:
- כתוב בספר = it is written in the book
- כתוב כאן = it is written here / it says here
Why is it בחשבון החשמל and not something like בחשבון החשמלי?
בחשבון החשמל means in/on the electricity bill.
Breakdown:
- ב־ = in / on
- חשבון = bill / account
- החשמל = the electricity
Here חשבון החשמל is a construct phrase (called smikhut), meaning:
- bill of the electricity
- naturally in English: the electricity bill
In Hebrew construct phrases, the definiteness often appears on the second noun:
- חשבון החשמל = the electricity bill
- not החשבון החשמל in this structure
So this is the normal Hebrew way to say it.
Why does only החשמל have ה־? Why not החשבון החשמל?
Because חשבון החשמל is a construct chain.
In Hebrew construct chains:
- the first noun usually does not take ה־
- the second noun carries the definiteness for the whole phrase
So:
- חשבון חשמל = an electricity bill
- חשבון החשמל = the electricity bill
This is a very important Hebrew pattern. More examples:
- בית ספר = a school
- בית הספר = the school
So בחשבון החשמל is exactly what you would expect grammatically.
What does התעריף mean, and why does it have ה־?
תעריף means rate, tariff, or sometimes pricing rate depending on context.
With ה־, it becomes התעריף = the tariff / the rate.
The sentence is talking about a specific rate, not just any rate, so the definite article makes sense.
Also, תעריף is masculine singular, which matters because the next word agrees with it.
Why is it שונה and not some other form?
שונה here agrees with התעריף, which is masculine singular.
So:
- masculine singular: שונה
- feminine singular: שונה
- masculine plural: שונים
- feminine plural: שונות
Even though masculine and feminine singular look the same here, the form is still chosen according to the noun it describes.
Since תעריף is masculine singular, שונה is the correct form.
Does שונה mean different or changed?
It can mean either, depending on context.
Common meanings of שונה include:
- different
- changed
- unusual (in some contexts)
In this sentence, the most natural meaning is usually different:
- התעריף שונה = the rate is different
But in some situations, a listener might also understand something close to the rate has changed. Context decides which nuance is stronger.
If Hebrew wanted to say very clearly has changed, it might use another wording such as:
- התעריף השתנה = the tariff/rate changed
So שונה here is descriptive, while השתנה is more clearly an action/change.
Is בחשבון החשמל really in the electricity bill or on the electricity bill?
Literally, ב־ usually means in. But in Hebrew, it is often used where English would say on, especially with written material.
So:
- כתוב בחשבון החשמל
- literally: written in the electricity bill
- natural English: written on the electricity bill
This is very normal. Hebrew often uses ב־ for something appearing inside a document, message, article, bill, contract, etc.
Why is the sentence ordered this way: כמו שכתוב בחשבון החשמל, התעריף שונה?
The sentence starts with a frame or reference point:
- כמו שכתוב בחשבון החשמל = as written on the electricity bill
Then it gives the main statement:
- התעריף שונה = the rate is different
This order is natural when the speaker wants to first point to the source of information and then make the claim.
English also does this:
- As written on the electricity bill, the rate is different
Hebrew could also rearrange things in some contexts, but this version sounds formal and clear.
What is the role of the comma in this sentence?
The comma separates the introductory phrase from the main clause.
So the structure is:
- introductory phrase: כמו שכתוב בחשבון החשמל
- main clause: התעריף שונה
The comma helps the reader process the sentence more easily. It is similar to English punctuation after an opening phrase like:
- As written on the electricity bill, ...
- According to the bill, ...
In informal writing, people are not always perfectly consistent with commas, but here the comma is helpful and natural.
How would this sentence sound if I said it out loud?
A simple pronunciation guide would be:
- k'mo she-kha-TUV be-khesh-BON ha-khash-MAL, ha-ta-A-rif sho-NEH
A few notes:
- כמו is often pronounced quickly, almost like k'mo
- כתוב is stressed on the last syllable: ka-TUV
- חשבון is stressed on the last syllable: khesh-BON
- חשמל is stressed on the last syllable: khash-MAL
- שונה is stressed on the last syllable: sho-NEH
The ח sound is a throaty sound with no exact English equivalent.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning HebrewMaster Hebrew — from כמו שכתוב בחשבון החשמל, התעריף שונה to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions