פרוטוקול מצב הדירה כולל ליקוי.

Questions & Answers about פרוטוקול מצב הדירה כולל ליקוי.

Why is it מצב הדירה and not המצב הדירה?

This is a construct chain in Hebrew, called סמיכות.

  • מצב = condition / state of
  • הדירה = the apartment

So מצב הדירה literally means the condition of the apartment.

In a construct chain, the first noun usually does not take ה־ even when the whole phrase is definite. The definiteness is carried by the second noun:

  • מצב דירה = apartment condition / condition of an apartment
  • מצב הדירה = the condition of the apartment

So המצב הדירה would be incorrect.

Why is the verb כולל and not כוללת?

Because the grammatical subject is פרוטוקול מצב הדירה, and the head noun of that subject is פרוטוקול, which is masculine singular.

Hebrew verbs in the present tense agree with the subject in gender and number:

  • כולל = masculine singular
  • כוללת = feminine singular
  • כוללים = masculine plural
  • כוללות = feminine plural

Even though דירה is feminine, it is not the main noun of the subject. The main noun is פרוטוקול, so the sentence uses כולל.

Is כולל really a verb here? It looks like an adjective or participle.

Yes. In modern Hebrew, the present tense is usually built from a form that historically functions like a participle. That means forms like כולל can behave like a verb in context.

Here, כולל means includes.

So:

  • המסמך כולל סעיף נוסף = the document includes an additional clause
  • הדו"ח כולל הערות = the report includes comments

A learner may notice that this form can sometimes feel adjective-like, but in sentences like this it functions as the normal present-tense verb.

Why is ליקוי without ה־?

Because it is indefinite here.

  • ליקוי = a defect / a flaw
  • הליקוי = the defect / the flaw

So the sentence is talking about some defect, not a specific already-known defect.

If you wanted to say the report includes the defect, you would say:

  • פרוטוקול מצב הדירה כולל את הליקוי

That version sounds more specific because it refers to a known defect.

Do you need את before ליקוי?

No, not in this sentence.

Hebrew uses את before a definite direct object. Since ליקוי here is indefinite, there is no את.

Compare:

  • כולל ליקוי = includes a defect
  • כולל את הליקוי = includes the defect

This is a very common rule in Hebrew:

  • definite object → usually takes את
  • indefinite object → no את
What exactly is ליקוי? Is it the normal word for defect?

Yes, ליקוי is a common formal word for defect, flaw, or deficiency.

It is often used in official, legal, technical, and inspection contexts, such as:

  • ליקויי בנייה = construction defects
  • ליקוי בטיחותי = a safety defect
  • ליקוי בדירה = a defect in an apartment

In everyday speech, people might also use words like:

  • פגם = blemish / defect
  • בעיה = problem

But ליקוי fits very naturally in a housing or inspection document.

What does פרוטוקול mean here? Is it the same as English protocol?

It is related to English protocol, but in Hebrew פרוטוקול often means an official written record, report, or documented form.

In this sentence, פרוטוקול מצב הדירה is something like:

  • an apartment condition report
  • a move-in / move-out inspection record
  • a written record of the apartment’s condition

So although the word looks familiar to an English speaker, the practical meaning here is closer to official report or inspection record than to the English sense of rules or procedure.

How is the sentence structured grammatically?

It follows a straightforward subject + verb + object pattern:

  • פרוטוקול מצב הדירה = subject
  • כולל = verb
  • ליקוי = direct object

So the structure is:

  • [The apartment condition report] [includes] [a defect].

This is a very common Hebrew sentence pattern and should feel fairly familiar to an English speaker.

How would this sentence be pronounced?

A natural pronunciation would be:

protokol matsav ha-dirah kolel likui

More closely broken down:

  • פרוטוקול = pro-to-KOL
  • מצב = ma-TSAV
  • הדירה = ha-di-RA
  • כולל = ko-LEL
  • ליקוי = li-KUI

The stress is usually on the last syllable in these words.

Could Hebrew also say this with של, like הפרוטוקול של מצב הדירה?

Grammatically, Hebrew often prefers the construct chain here:

  • פרוטוקול מצב הדירה

Using של would sound less natural in this kind of formal phrase. Hebrew tends to use סמיכות for compact noun combinations, especially in official or written language.

So:

  • פרוטוקול מצב הדירה = the natural/formal phrasing
  • הפרוטוקול של מצב הדירה = possible in some contexts, but not the usual wording here
Is the whole phrase פרוטוקול מצב הדירה definite even though פרוטוקול has no ה־?

Yes. In a construct chain, if the second noun is definite, the whole chain becomes definite.

Since הדירה means the apartment, the phrase מצב הדירה means the condition of the apartment, and פרוטוקול מצב הדירה refers to the apartment’s condition report in a definite sense.

This is a key feature of Hebrew noun chains:

  • only the final noun normally shows the article
  • but the whole phrase can still be definite

So a learner should not expect definiteness marking on every noun in the chain.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
Your avatar
“What's the best way to learn Hebrew grammar?”
Hebrew grammar becomes intuitive with practice. Focus on understanding the core patterns first — how sentences are structured, how verbs change form, and how words relate to each other. Our course breaks these concepts into small lessons so you can build understanding step by step.

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Hebrew

Master Hebrew — from פרוטוקול מצב הדירה כולל ליקוי to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions