Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching German grammar and vocabulary.
Start learning German now
Questions & Answers about Ich erklärte gestern den Zweck des Projekts vor der Klasse.
Why is den Zweck in the accusative case?
den Zweck is the direct object of the verb erklären. In German, whatever you “explain” is the thing you explain to someone, and that thing takes the accusative case. Zweck is a masculine noun, so its accusative singular article is den (rather than der).
Why is des Projekts in the genitive, and can I say des Projektes or vom Projekt instead?
des Projekts shows possession: the purpose of the project. Both des Projekts and des Projektes are grammatically correct genitive forms of das Projekt; the shorter -s ending is more common in modern usage. You can also use the more colloquial construction vom Projekt (a contraction of von dem Projekt), but genitive is often preferred in formal or written German.
Why is vor der Klasse used here, and why is der Klasse dative?
vor is a two-way preposition. When it indicates a static location (“in front of”), it requires the dative case. Klasse is feminine, so its dative singular article is der. Here vor der Klasse means “in front of the class” (physically addressing the students).
Could I instead say Ich erklärte der Klasse den Zweck des Projekts?
Yes. That shifts der Klasse to a dative object meaning “to the class,” rather than a locational phrase.
• Ich erklärte der Klasse den Zweck… = “I explained the purpose to the class.”
• Ich erklärte den Zweck … vor der Klasse. = “I explained the purpose in front of the class,” emphasizing the physical setting.
Why is gestern placed after the verb and before the object?
German typically follows the Time–Manner–Place (TMP) order for adverbs. With a normal subject-verb start, a time adverbial like gestern comes right after the verb:
Subject (Ich) – Verb (erklärte) – Time (gestern) – Object (den Zweck…) – Place (vor der Klasse).
If you begin with gestern, you must still keep the verb in second position:
Gestern erklärte ich ….
Why use the simple past erklärte instead of the present perfect habe erklärt?
In written narrative or formal contexts, German often uses the Präteritum (simple past) for verbs like erklären. In spoken everyday German, the Perfekt (“Ich habe … erklärt”) is more common. Both are correct; the choice depends on style and register.
Do all nouns Zweck, Projekt, Klasse have to be capitalized?
Yes. German orthography dictates that every noun is capitalized, no matter where it appears in the sentence.
Why is there a definite article den before Zweck? Could it be omitted?
Here you refer to the specific purpose of a known project, so you need the definite article den. Omitting it or using an indefinite article (einen Zweck) would change the meaning to something more general (“a purpose,” not “the purpose”).
Could I say in der Klasse instead of vor der Klasse?
You could, but it slightly alters the nuance:
• in der Klasse = “inside the classroom,” focusing on location.
• vor der Klasse = “in front of the class,” emphasizing that you addressed the group (e.g. giving a presentation).
Why not use Wozu habe ich gestern noch … erklärt? as a question form?
To form an indirect question about purpose, German uses wozu (“to what end?”). However, in a direct statement of what you did, you keep the neutral Ich erklärte gestern … structure. If you want to ask “Why did I explain…?” you would say Warum habe ich gestern … erklärt?, not wozu.
