Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching German grammar and vocabulary.
Questions & Answers about Der Apfelsaft war gestern im Angebot, deswegen habe ich gleich zwei Flaschen genommen.
Why does the sentence use war instead of ist?
Because the sale happened in the past (yesterday). In German, ist (present tense) describes a current state, whereas war is the Präteritum (simple past) of sein, indicating that the Apfelsaft was on sale at a specific past time.
Why is the first clause in Präteritum (war) but the second clause in Perfekt (habe genommen)?
German often mixes Präteritum and Perfekt depending on context and verb:
- Präteritum (war) is common in written narratives and is the usual past form of sein.
- Perfekt (habe genommen) is typical in spoken language for completed actions.
So using war for “was on sale” and habe genommen for the action of “taking” feels natural, especially in everyday speech.
What does im Angebot mean, and why is it in the dative case?
- im is a contraction of in dem.
- Angebot (offer/sale) here denotes a state (“to be on sale”).
With in indicating a static location or state, German takes the dative case. Hence im Angebot means “on sale.”
Why is there a comma before deswegen?