Breakdown of Der Fahrer darf den Hund nicht überfahren.
Questions & Answers about Der Fahrer darf den Hund nicht überfahren.
Why are Fahrer and Hund capitalized?
Because in German, all nouns are capitalized.
So in this sentence:
- der Fahrer = the driver
- der Hund = the dog
This is one of the first big spelling differences English speakers notice.
Why is it der Fahrer?
Der Fahrer is the subject of the sentence — the one doing the action or being talked about.
German marks that role with case. Here, the subject is in the nominative case.
- der = masculine nominative singular
- Fahrer = driver
So der Fahrer means the driver as the subject.
Why is it den Hund and not der Hund?
Because den Hund is the direct object — the thing affected by the action.
The verb überfahren takes a direct object, and a masculine noun in the accusative case uses den, not der.
So:
- der Hund = the dog as a subject
- den Hund = the dog as a direct object
That is why the sentence has den Hund.
What does darf mean here?
Darf is the 3rd person singular present tense of dürfen, a modal verb.
Its basic meaning is:
- dürfen = to be allowed to / may
So:
- er darf = he is allowed to / he may
But in the negative, nicht dürfen usually means:
- must not
- is not allowed to
So in this sentence, it is not just weak possibility. It expresses prohibition.
Why is überfahren not conjugated?
Because after a modal verb like dürfen, the main verb usually stays in the infinitive.
So German does this:
- Der Fahrer darf ... überfahren.
not:
- Der Fahrer darf ... überfährt.
The conjugated verb is darf, and überfahren stays in its basic form.
Why is überfahren at the end of the sentence?
That is normal German word order with a modal verb in a main clause.
German often works like this:
- the conjugated verb goes in position 2
- the infinitive goes to the end
So the structure is:
- Der Fahrer = subject
- darf = conjugated modal verb
- den Hund nicht überfahren = the rest, with the infinitive at the end
English speakers often find this strange at first, but it is very common in German.
Why is nicht before überfahren?
Here, nicht is negating the action überfahren.
A very common pattern with modal verbs is:
- modal verb + object + nicht + infinitive
So:
- Der Fahrer darf den Hund nicht überfahren.
This means the action of running over the dog is not allowed.
In neutral word order, this placement sounds natural.
Does nicht dürfen mean may not or must not?
In most normal situations, nicht dürfen means must not / is not allowed to.
That is important, because English may not can be ambiguous:
- You may not go can mean you are not allowed to go
- but it can also sound like perhaps you won’t go
German nicht dürfen is usually not ambiguous in that way. It normally expresses a rule or prohibition.
So this sentence is best understood as:
- The driver must not run over the dog
- The driver is not allowed to run over the dog
Is überfahren a separable verb here?
No — in this sentence, überfahren is the inseparable verb meaning to run over.
That matters because some German verbs with prefixes can be separable or inseparable depending on meaning.
Here, the clue is what happens when the verb is used without a modal:
- Der Fahrer überfährt den Hund nicht.
You do not say:
- Der Fahrer fährt den Hund nicht über.
So for this meaning, it behaves as an inseparable verb.
How is überfahren stressed and pronounced here?
In this meaning, the stress is on fahren, not on über:
- überFAHren
That stress pattern goes with the inseparable verb meaning to run over.
A learner does not need perfect phonetics immediately, but it helps to know that the stress is not on the first syllable here.
Could the word order be different?
Yes, but changing the word order usually changes the focus or emphasis.
The most neutral version is:
- Der Fahrer darf den Hund nicht überfahren.
If you say:
- Der Fahrer darf nicht den Hund überfahren.
that sounds more like:
- It is not the dog that the driver may run over
or - The driver must not run over the dog specifically
In other words, it sounds contrastive, as if you are correcting someone.
So the original sentence is the normal, neutral way to say it.
Does der Fahrer have to mean a male driver?
Grammatically, der Fahrer is a masculine noun.
In many contexts, that suggests a male driver. A specifically female form would be:
- die Fahrerin
However, depending on context, masculine job nouns have sometimes also been used more generally. Still, in a simple sentence like this, many learners should understand der Fahrer as most naturally referring to a male driver.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Der Fahrer darf den Hund nicht überfahren to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions