Breakdown of Festplatte und Cloudspeicher enthalten dieselbe Sicherungskopie.
Questions & Answers about Festplatte und Cloudspeicher enthalten dieselbe Sicherungskopie.
Why is the verb enthalten and not enthält?
Because the subject is plural.
The subject is Festplatte und Cloudspeicher = hard drive and cloud storage. Two nouns joined by und usually make a plural subject, so the verb must also be plural:
- die Festplatte enthält = the hard drive contains
- der Cloudspeicher enthält = the cloud storage contains
- Festplatte und Cloudspeicher enthalten = the hard drive and cloud storage contain
So enthalten is the correct 3rd person plural form.
Why is there no article before Festplatte or Cloudspeicher?
German often leaves out articles in general statements, headings, labels, or when the sentence is talking about things in a broad, non-specific way.
So:
- Die Festplatte und der Cloudspeicher enthalten ... would also be possible if you mean specific items
- Festplatte und Cloudspeicher enthalten ... sounds more general, like a neutral statement about those two storage locations
English also sometimes does something similar in short labels or technical writing, though German allows it a bit more naturally in some contexts.
Is Cloudspeicher singular or plural here?
Here it is singular.
The noun itself is singular: der Cloudspeicher.
Its plural can also be die Cloudspeicher.
In this sentence, Cloudspeicher is singular, but the whole subject becomes plural because it is joined with Festplatte by und:
- Festplatte = singular
- Cloudspeicher = singular
- Festplatte und Cloudspeicher = plural together
That is why the verb is enthalten.
Why does it say dieselbe Sicherungskopie? What does dieselbe mean?
Dieselbe means the very same or one and the same.
It is stronger than just saying two things are similar. The sentence means both storage locations contain one identical backup copy, not merely similar copies.
German often distinguishes:
- dieselbe = the same one
- die gleiche = an equivalent one / one just like it
In everyday speech, many people use them less strictly, but the formal distinction is:
- dieselbe Datei = literally the exact same file
- die gleiche Datei = a file of the same kind, sometimes a separate copy depending on context
So dieselbe Sicherungskopie emphasizes identity.
Why is it dieselbe and not dieselben or dasselbe?
Because Sicherungskopie is:
- feminine: die Sicherungskopie
- singular
- in the accusative case here, because it is the direct object of enthalten
For a feminine singular noun in nominative or accusative, the form is dieselbe.
Compare:
- derselbe Speicher = masculine singular
- dieselbe Sicherungskopie = feminine singular
- dasselbe Backup = neuter singular
- dieselben Dateien = plural
So the ending matches the gender and number of Sicherungskopie.
What case is dieselbe Sicherungskopie?
It is in the accusative case.
The verb enthalten takes a direct object: what is being contained?
- Festplatte und Cloudspeicher = subject
- enthalten = verb
- dieselbe Sicherungskopie = direct object
So the question is:
- What do the hard drive and cloud storage contain?
Dieselbe Sicherungskopie.
That makes it accusative.
Because Sicherungskopie is feminine, the accusative singular form looks the same as the nominative singular form:
- nominative: dieselbe Sicherungskopie
- accusative: dieselbe Sicherungskopie
What gender is Sicherungskopie, and how can I tell?
It is feminine: die Sicherungskopie.
A useful clue is the ending -kopie, which is almost always feminine in German:
- die Kopie
- die Fotokopie
- die Sicherungskopie
Also, the first part of a compound noun does not decide the gender. The last part usually does. Since the base noun is Kopie, the compound Sicherungskopie is also feminine.
How do the compound nouns work in this sentence?
German very often combines nouns into one long noun.
Here you have:
Festplatte = fest
- Platte
Literally something like fixed plate, but the actual meaning is hard drive or hard disk
- Platte
Cloudspeicher = Cloud
- Speicher
Literally cloud storage
- Speicher
Sicherungskopie = Sicherung
- Kopie
Literally backup copy
- Kopie
In German, these compounds are written as one word. The final part is the main noun, and it determines the gender and plural behavior.
Could I also say die gleiche Sicherungskopie instead of dieselbe Sicherungskopie?
You may hear that in everyday speech, but dieselbe is better if you want to be precise.
Traditional distinction:
- dieselbe Sicherungskopie = literally the exact same backup copy
- die gleiche Sicherungskopie = a backup copy of the same kind, or one that is identical, but not necessarily the exact same one
In real-life German, many speakers use die gleiche where stricter grammar would prefer dieselbe. Still, for learners, it is good to understand that dieselbe is the more exact choice here.
Can the word order be changed?
Yes, but the verb still has to stay in the second position in a normal main clause.
The neutral order is:
- Festplatte und Cloudspeicher enthalten dieselbe Sicherungskopie.
You could also front the object for emphasis:
- Dieselbe Sicherungskopie enthalten Festplatte und Cloudspeicher.
That is grammatically possible, but it sounds more marked or stylistically emphasized. The original sentence is the most natural neutral version.
Why are all these nouns capitalized?
Because in German, all nouns are capitalized.
So in this sentence:
- Festplatte
- Cloudspeicher
- Sicherungskopie
are capitalized simply because they are nouns.
This is a standard rule of German spelling and is one of the big visual differences from English.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Festplatte und Cloudspeicher enthalten dieselbe Sicherungskopie to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions