Breakdown of Li redaktas portreton same kiel memfoton.
Questions & Answers about Li redaktas portreton same kiel memfoton.
Why do portreton and memfoton both end in -n?
Because both are functioning as direct objects.
- portreto = portrait
- portreton = portrait as the object of the verb
- memfoto = selfie
- memfoton = selfie as the object of the verb
In Esperanto, the direct object usually takes the -n ending.
Here, Li redaktas portreton means He edits a portrait.
The -n on memfoton is there because it is being compared in the same grammatical role: the sentence is basically saying he edits a portrait in the same way that he edits a selfie.
What does same kiel mean?
same kiel means like, just like, or in the same way as.
A helpful breakdown is:
- same = similarly, in the same way
- kiel = as, like
So same kiel memfoton means something like just like a selfie or in the same way as a selfie.
It is a very common Esperanto pattern for making comparisons.
Why is there no word for a before portrait or selfie?
Esperanto does not have an indefinite article.
English has:
- a portrait
- a selfie
Esperanto simply says:
- portreto
- memfoto
Esperanto does have a definite article, la, for the, but there is no separate word for a/an.
So:
- portreton = a portrait or the portrait, depending on context
- memfoton = a selfie or the selfie, depending on context
Is memfoton one word? How is it formed?
Yes, it is one word, and it is a compound noun.
It is built from:
- mem = self
- foto = photo
So:
- memfoto = self-photo, meaning selfie
- memfoton = selfie as a direct object
Compounds are very common in Esperanto. Usually, the main idea comes at the end. Here, the main noun is foto, and mem modifies it.
Why is the verb redaktas and what does the -as mean?
redaktas is the present-tense form of the verb redakti, meaning to edit.
Esperanto verb endings are regular:
- -i = infinitive, to edit → redakti
- -as = present tense, edits / is editing
- -is = past tense
- -os = future tense
So:
- Li redaktas = He edits or He is editing
One nice thing about Esperanto is that verb forms do not change depending on the subject.
So:
- mi redaktas
- li redaktas
- ili redaktas
all use -as for the present tense.
Could the word order be changed?
Yes, to some extent.
The most neutral order is:
- Li redaktas portreton same kiel memfoton.
But Esperanto allows some flexibility because the -n ending shows which noun is the direct object.
For example, portreton li redaktas... would still be understandable, though it would sound more marked or emphatic.
So the usual order here is preferred, but the grammar does not depend only on position the way English often does.
Why is memfoton also in the accusative after kiel?
Because it matches the grammatical role of portreton.
Even though kiel introduces a comparison, memfoton still represents something being compared as an object. You can think of it as a shortened version of a fuller idea, something like:
- Li redaktas portreton same kiel li redaktas memfoton.
In the shorter version, the second verb is omitted, but memfoton keeps the object ending because it still belongs to that same structure.
This is a point that can feel unusual to English speakers, since English does not mark direct objects with a special ending.
Why is it Li and not li in lowercase?
Because it is the first word of the sentence.
In Esperanto, pronouns are normally lowercase:
- li = he
But like in English, the first word of a sentence is capitalized:
- Li redaktas...
So this is just normal capitalization, not a special grammatical form.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning EsperantoMaster Esperanto — from Li redaktas portreton same kiel memfoton to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions