Breakdown of Quantes espelmes necessitem? En necessitem sis per al pastís.
Questions & Answers about Quantes espelmes necessitem? En necessitem sis per al pastís.
Why does the sentence use quantes?
Because quantes means how many and it agrees with the noun it refers to.
Here the noun is espelmes (candles), which is feminine plural, so Catalan uses:
- quants for masculine plural
- quantes for feminine plural
So:
- Quantes espelmes...? = How many candles...?
This agreement is something English does not do with how many, but Catalan does.
What form is necessitem?
Necessitem is the 1st person plural present indicative of necessitar (to need).
So it means:
- necessitem = we need
A few related forms are:
- necessito = I need
- necessites = you need
- necessita = he/she/it needs
- necessitem = we need
- necessiteu = you all need
- necessiten = they need
In both sentences, the subject is we, even though Catalan does not need to state nosaltres.
Why isn’t we written in the sentence?
Catalan often leaves out subject pronouns when the verb ending already makes the subject clear.
So instead of saying:
- Nosaltres necessitem...
Catalan very naturally says:
- Necessitem...
Because -em in necessitem already tells you it means we.
This is very common in Catalan, just as in Spanish or Italian.
What does en mean in En necessitem sis?
Here en is a pronoun that replaces espelmes.
So the second sentence literally works like:
- En necessitem sis = We need six of them
It avoids repeating espelmes.
You can think of it as referring back to an unspecified quantity of something already mentioned:
- Quantes espelmes necessitem?
- En necessitem sis.
That is basically:
- How many candles do we need?
- We need six (of them).
This en is very common in Catalan when talking about quantities.
Why does en come before the verb?
Because en is an unstressed object pronoun, and in normal affirmative sentences in Catalan, these pronouns usually go before the conjugated verb.
So:
- En necessitem sis
not:
- Necessitem en sis
This is standard pronoun placement in Catalan.
Very roughly:
- en
- verb + quantity
Examples:
- En vull dos = I want two of them
- En tenim moltes = We have many of them
- En necessitem sis = We need six of them
Could you also say Necessitem sis espelmes per al pastís?
Yes, absolutely.
That would be a fully natural sentence meaning:
- We need six candles for the cake
The version with en is used because espelmes was already mentioned in the question, so Catalan prefers not to repeat the noun unnecessarily.
So both are correct:
- Necessitem sis espelmes per al pastís
- En necessitem sis per al pastís
The second one sounds more connected to the previous question.
Why is the verb repeated in the answer instead of just saying sis?
You can answer with just Sis in conversation, especially if the context is obvious.
But En necessitem sis is a fuller, more complete answer. It sounds natural and clear, and it shows the normal Catalan structure for answering a quantity question.
So these are all possible, with slightly different levels of completeness:
- Sis. = Six.
- Sis espelmes. = Six candles.
- En necessitem sis. = We need six of them.
The sentence you were given is useful because it teaches the grammar pattern, not just the shortest possible reply.
What exactly does per al mean?
Per al means for the.
It is made from:
- per a = for
- el = the
So:
- per a + el = per al
That gives:
- per al pastís = for the cake
This is a very common combination in Catalan.
Why is it per al pastís and not just pel pastís?
Because per al comes from per a + el, while pel comes from per + el.
In standard Catalan, many learners are taught:
- per al = for the
- pel = by the / through the / along the / because of the, depending on context
So in this sentence, the idea is purpose:
- six candles for the cake
That is why per al pastís is the expected form.
You may sometimes hear variation in informal speech or depending on dialect, but for learners, per al pastís is the safest standard choice here.
Why is espelmes plural, and how do I know it is feminine?
Espelma means candle. Its plural is espelmes.
It is feminine, so:
- singular: una espelma
- plural: unes espelmes
That feminine gender is why the question uses:
- quantes espelmes
not:
- quants espelmes
In Catalan, adjectives, articles, and words like quants/quantes often agree in gender and number with the noun.
Why does sis not change form?
Because sis is the number six, and in this use it does not change for gender.
So you say:
- sis espelmes = six candles
- sis llibres = six books
Unlike one or two hundred, some numbers may vary in certain languages, but sis stays the same here.
What is the role of pastís in the sentence?
Pastís means cake.
In per al pastís, it tells you the purpose of the candles:
- the six candles are for the cake
So the structure is:
- En necessitem sis = We need six of them
- per al pastís = for the cake
Together:
- En necessitem sis per al pastís = We need six of them for the cake
Is the question mark used the same way as in English?
Yes. Catalan uses the normal closing question mark:
- Quantes espelmes necessitem?
Unlike Spanish, Catalan does not use an opening inverted question mark (¿).
So the punctuation here is very similar to English.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CatalanMaster Catalan — from Quantes espelmes necessitem? En necessitem sis per al pastís to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions