Breakdown of بالنسبة للحضور، الغياب مشكلة.
Questions & Answers about بالنسبة للحضور، الغياب مشكلة.
What does بالنسبة لـ mean here?
بالنسبة لـ is a very common expression meaning regarding, as for, or when it comes to.
So:
بالنسبة للحضور = regarding attendance / as for attendance
It introduces the topic before the main statement.
Why is it للحضور and not لـ الحضور?
Because لـ and الـ combine in writing.
- لـ = to / for
- الحضور = the attendance
So:
لـ + الحضور = للحضور
This is completely normal in Arabic spelling. In pronunciation, it is something like lel-ḥoḍoor or lil-ḥuḍūr, depending on the variety and how formal the speech is.
Why is there no word for is in الغياب مشكلة?
In Arabic, present-tense nominal sentences usually do not use a separate word for is/am/are.
So:
الغياب مشكلة
literally: the absence a problem
natural English: Absence is a problem
This is a basic Arabic pattern.
If you wanted past or future, then Arabic would usually use a verb:
- كان الغياب مشكلة = Absence was a problem
- in Egyptian, something like الغياب هيبقى مشكلة = Absence will be a problem
Which part is the main sentence, and which part is just setting the topic?
The main sentence is:
الغياب مشكلة = Absence is a problem
The opening phrase:
بالنسبة للحضور = As for attendance / Regarding attendance
just sets the topic or frame.
So the whole sentence works like:
As for attendance, absence is a problem.
This topic-first structure is very common in Arabic.
Why does الغياب have الـ, but مشكلة does not?
This is a very common Arabic pattern:
- الغياب is definite: the absence or absence as a known/general concept
- مشكلة is indefinite: a problem
So the sentence means:
الغياب مشكلة = Absence is a problem
If you made مشكلة definite too, as in الغياب المشكلة, the meaning would change toward Absence is the problem, which is much more specific and contrastive.
So the indefinite مشكلة is the normal choice for classifying something:
X is a problem, X is a good idea, X is a mistake, etc.
Is this sentence natural in Egyptian Arabic, or does it sound formal?
It is understandable in Egyptian Arabic, but it sounds somewhat formal or written.
The structure itself is fine, but بالنسبة لـ often feels a bit formal or administrative, especially in a short statement like this.
In everyday Egyptian speech, people might also say things like:
- في موضوع الحضور، الغياب مشكلة
- لو بنتكلم عن الحضور، الغياب مشكلة
- بالنسبة للحضور، الغياب مشكلة
still possible, just a bit more formal
So yes, an Egyptian speaker would understand it easily, but it leans more toward Modern Standard Arabic / formal spoken Arabic than very casual conversation.
How would an Egyptian speaker usually pronounce this sentence?
A natural Egyptian-style pronunciation would be approximately:
belnesba lel-ḥoḍoor, el-gheyāb moshkela
A few useful notes:
- الـ is usually pronounced el- in Egyptian
- حضور sounds like ḥoḍoor
- غياب often sounds like gheyāb
- مشكلة is commonly moshkela
- the final ة in مشكلة is pronounced like -a in normal speech
So the sentence does not sound exactly like very formal classroom pronunciation.
Why is there a comma after للحضور?
The comma marks a pause between the topic phrase and the main statement.
So the rhythm is:
بالنسبة للحضور، | الغياب مشكلة
In speech, you would usually make a small pause there.
Arabic punctuation is somewhat flexible in everyday writing, so you may sometimes see the sentence without a comma, but using one here is helpful and natural.
Can I change the word order?
Yes, but the emphasis changes.
The original:
بالنسبة للحضور، الغياب مشكلة
puts attendance first as the topic.
Another possible order is:
الغياب مشكلة بالنسبة للحضور
which means something like Absence is a problem when it comes to attendance
Both are understandable, but the original version is better if you want to introduce attendance as the topic first.
Does الحضور mean attendance or presence?
It can mean either, depending on context.
- In school, work, records, schedules, and administration, الحضور usually means attendance
- In other contexts, it can mean presence
Likewise, الغياب can mean absence generally, but in school or work it often means being absent
So if this sentence is about students, employees, or meetings, attendance is the most likely meaning.
Do I need to worry about case endings here?
Not for Egyptian Arabic.
In full formal Arabic grammar, the sentence could be analyzed with case endings, but in Egyptian Arabic those endings are not pronounced. Even many speakers using formal Arabic in normal life do not fully pronounce them.
So for an Egyptian learner, it is enough to learn and say:
بالنسبة للحضور، الغياب مشكلة
without worrying about nominative or genitive endings in speech.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning ArabicMaster Arabic — from بالنسبة للحضور، الغياب مشكلة to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions