Налоговый вычет выбрали исходя из расходов на лечение.

Breakdown of Налоговый вычет выбрали исходя из расходов на лечение.

выбрать
to choose
налоговый вычет
the tax deduction
расходы на лечение
the medical expenses
исходя из
based on; on the basis of

Questions & Answers about Налоговый вычет выбрали исходя из расходов на лечение.

Why is налоговый вычет not visibly marked as the object of выбрали?

It actually is the direct object, but in this sentence the form looks the same as the nominative.

  • выбрать takes the accusative case.
  • вычет is an inanimate masculine noun.
  • For inanimate masculine singular nouns, the accusative = nominative.

So:

  • nominative: налоговый вычет
  • accusative: налоговый вычет

That is why the object does not change its form here.

Why is выбрали plural if there is no subject?

Russian often uses a 3rd person plural past tense with no stated subject to mean they chose, someone chose, or it was chosen in an impersonal/indefinite way.

So выбрали does not necessarily mean a specific they. In official or bureaucratic language, it often works a lot like an English passive:

  • Налоговый вычет выбрали... = The tax deduction was chosen... / They chose the tax deduction...

This is very common in Russian.

Why is it выбрали, not выбирали?

Because выбрали is perfective, and it presents the action as completed.

  • выбрали = they chose / they have chosen
  • выбирали = they were choosing / they used to choose / they chose repeatedly or with focus on process

In this sentence, the result matters: a deduction was selected, so perfective выбрали is the natural choice.

What does исходя из mean here?

Исходя из is a very common expression meaning:

  • based on
  • proceeding from
  • taking into account
  • on the basis of

So the sentence says that the deduction was chosen based on the treatment expenses.

Although исходя originally comes from a verb, исходя из is very often learned and used as a fixed expression.

What case comes after исходя из?

It takes the genitive case.

That is why you get:

  • из расходов
  • not из расходы

This is similar to many other uses of из, which also require the genitive.

Why is it расходов, not расходы?

Because расходов is the genitive plural form of расходы.

Here that happens for two reasons:

  1. исходя из requires the genitive.
  2. расходы is naturally plural in the meaning expenses/costs.

So:

Why is it на лечение?

Because Russian commonly says расходы на что? = expenses for/on what?

So:

  • расходы на лечение = expenses for treatment
  • расходы на обучение = expenses for education
  • расходы на ремонт = expenses for repairs

The preposition на here takes the accusative.

Why does лечение not change form after на?

It is in the accusative, but the accusative form is identical to the nominative for this noun.

Лечение is a neuter inanimate noun, so:

  • nominative: лечение
  • accusative: лечение

That is why you do not see a visible ending change.

Is исходя a gerund, and if so, why is there no comma?

Yes, historically исходя is an adverbial participle (often called a verbal adverb or gerund-like form), from исходить.

However, in modern Russian исходя из is very often treated almost like a fixed prepositional expression meaning based on. In formal and bureaucratic language, it is commonly written without a comma when it is closely tied to the predicate.

So in a sentence like this, no comma is normal.

Could I move the words around?

Yes. Russian word order is flexible, and the meaning would stay similar, though the emphasis changes.

For example:

  • Налоговый вычет выбрали исходя из расходов на лечение.
  • Выбрали налоговый вычет исходя из расходов на лечение.

The original version puts налоговый вычет first as the topic: as for the tax deduction, it was chosen...

That kind of word order is especially common in formal written Russian.

Could this sentence be translated actively or passively?

Yes. Because Russian uses an indefinite выбрали with no subject, English can often translate it in more than one way.

Possible translations include:

  • They chose the tax deduction based on treatment expenses.
  • The tax deduction was chosen based on treatment expenses.
  • The deduction was selected on the basis of treatment expenses.

In natural English, the passive is often best if the agent is unknown or unimportant.

Why is расходы used instead of a singular word meaning expense?

In Russian, расходы is the normal word for expenses/costs in financial, legal, and bureaucratic language. Even when English might use a more abstract singular like expense or cost, Russian often prefers the plural.

So расходы на лечение is the standard collocation for medical/treatment expenses.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
Your avatar
“What's the best way to learn Russian grammar?”
Russian grammar becomes intuitive with practice. Focus on understanding the core patterns first — how sentences are structured, how verbs change form, and how words relate to each other. Our course breaks these concepts into small lessons so you can build understanding step by step.

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Russian

Master Russian — from Налоговый вычет выбрали исходя из расходов на лечение to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions