Breakdown of Der Bericht muss sorgfältig geprüft worden sein.
Questions & Answers about Der Bericht muss sorgfältig geprüft worden sein.
In German, when you have a present‐tense modal verb (muss) combined with a perfect passive, you create a verb cluster at the clause end. It consists of:
- geprüft (the past participle of prüfen)
- worden (the past participle of werden, used to form the passive)
- sein (the infinitive auxiliary you need for the perfect tense)
This stacking of participles and infinitives is the normal word‐order rule for a perfect passive with a modal.
There are two past participles of werden in German:
- geworden is used when werden means “to become.”
- worden is the special past participle used only in passive‐voice constructions.
In a perfect passive you must use worden, not geworden.
In a normal perfect tense (active or passive), German uses haben or sein as an auxiliary. For the perfect passive you would say:
“Der Bericht ist sorgfältig geprüft worden.”
When you add a modal in front, you shift sein out of its finite form into an infinitive. Hence it appears at the very end.
The pattern is:
- put the modal in its finite form (here muss)
- turn the perfect passive auxiliaries into infinitives (i.e. worden, sein)
- keep the past participle of the main verb (here geprüft) just before them
Result: muss ... geprüft worden sein
Invert muss and the subject, then keep the verb cluster at the end:
“Muss der Bericht sorgfältig geprüft worden sein?”
You place nicht before the adverbial or the verb cluster:
“Der Bericht muss nicht sorgfältig geprüft worden sein.”
This construction negates the whole necessity‐plus‐completion idea.